Mother says daughter’s health has declined at day program where she has few meaningful activities
At her day program in the Liberty Tree Mall in Danvers, a young woman spends lots of time either walking around the mall with other clients, isolated from the community or engaging in computer games and a handful of other repetitive and mundane activities, according to her mother.
The mother said her daughter has told her she has asked many times to participate in job training and internships at Parcels, a boutique in the mall. Parcels is run by the Northeast Arc, a corporate provider to the Department of Developmental Services (DDS). Northeast Arc runs both the daughter’s day program and her group home.
We are not disclosing the names of either the mother or daughter, at the mother’s request.
According to the mother, her daughter says the day program director repeatedly responds to her requests to work at Parcels by saying she will “‘look into it,'” but nothing ever comes of it.
Since the daughter began attending the day program in October 2021, the staff have allowed her, over the mother’s objections, to buy candy and lemonade at the Five Below store there. The mother thinks the combination of her daughter’s sugar intake and lack of exercise at the day program may have contributed to her development of diabetes, which was diagnosed in October.
Yet, the mother says, neither Northeast Arc nor DDS, which funds the provider agency, appear to recognize the problem.
The mother said she has requested that the day program staff help her daughter to make better food choices, and provide her with activities other than making purchases in mall stores. But, she said, the day program management have responded that while they encourage the daughter to make good choices, it is her “human right” to buy what she wants.
The mother said the day program management suggested that the solution to the problem is to take her daughter’s debit card away from her or to suspend her participation in the program altogether. The mother maintains that neither of those suggestions are constructive because neither would provide her daughter with cues for appropriate behaviors or with usable skills.
The daughter’s day program is called STEP ( Skills Training Exploration Program), and is described on the Northeast Arc website as helping participants “build work and life skills.” But, the mother said, little or no such skill-or-work-related training is being provided to her daughter in the program.
The daughter, who is 26, has a moderate intellectual disability. She has lived in three group homes run by three different DDS providers; but her mother said that none of those settings have met her needs as required by DDS regulations.
We are hearing more and more from families and guardians that the COVID pandemic hastened a decline in overall care and services in the DDS community-based system. The decline has been marked by an ongoing staffing shortage. But the mother maintains the staffing shortage doesn’t fully explain the lack of meaningful activities provided by the daughter’s day program.
The mother said Northeast Arc frequently extols its programs on social media and in podcasts. Recently, a Northeast Arc executive contended on a corporate podcast that the organization has helped more people with disabilities secure employment during the pandemic than in any previous year. “As I listen or read these things, I wonder – who does this apply to? Why isn’t this (her daughter’s) reality?” the mother wrote to us.
Declining health
The mother said her daughter’s mental and physical health have declined in the past several months. In addition to diabetes, the daughter was diagnosed earlier this year with metabolic syndrome, a condition that can increase the risk of heart disease and stroke. She also developed fatty liver disease a year ago as well as narcolepsy.
The mother said Northeast Arc recently developed a behavior plan to address these issues; but she termed the plan “weak,” and said the staff are “woefully undertrained.” Also, she said, the plan has been implemented in the daughter’s group home, but not at her day program.
Seeking self-directed model and requesting a change in placement
Earlier this year, the mother asked DDS officials whether the Department’s “self-directed services” model might work better for her daughter than the traditional model of care under which DDS directly funds corporate providers to provide residential and day program services. Although DDS has been operating self-directed services programs since the late 1990s, the state Legislature authorized a major expansion of those programs in 2014 with passage of the “Real Lives” law.
The mother said provider and DDS officials met with her to discuss her self-directed services proposal, and recommended for the first time last month that she explore a shared-living arrangement for her daughter. The mother said they told her the self-directed model could be made to work with shared-living services.
The mother said she and her husband have agreed to explore the shared-living model, although she said her daughter has said she would like to remain in a group home. Under the shared-living proposal, the daughter would live in a home near her parents. A shared-living setting is run by an individual provider.
The mother said she and her husband also asked to explore another group home placement for their daughter, particularly one that is state-operated. As we have reported, staff in state-run group homes and Intermediate Care Facilities in Massachusetts are better paid and better trained than their counterparts in the corporate provider-run group home system.
The mother said the response from DDS, though, has been that they typically refer only medically complex and highly clinically or behaviorally challenged individuals to state-operated facilities, and that those settings would not be an appropriate peer match for her daughter. She added that DDS has also claimed residential placements are scarce, and there are no other residential placements in the surrounding community.
We disagree that state-operated placements are only appropriate for a restricted set of clients. In any case, it appears that the daughter’s medical needs have become more acute in the past year.
Lack of exercise and concern over diet
The mother said that in August, when her daughter’s gastroenterologist diagnosed her with fatty liver disease, he recommended a half-hour-a-day exercise program for her, five days a week, and a low fat diet.
To date, the mother said, her daughter has no regular exercise program either at her day program or in her group home. She said staff maintain that they encourage her daughter to exercise and eat healthy foods, but that they contend she is a picky eater and she refuses exercise.
In September, with her daughter’s health issues unaddressed, a sleep specialist at Mass Eye and Ear determined that the daughter was experiencing excessive daytime sleepiness and that she might have narcolepsy, the mother said. In late October, her primary care doctor stated that her daughter’s condition had shifted from prediabetic to diabetic. The doctor’s notes stated that her group home was working on diet and exercise programs for her; but the mother said the group home has not been doing that.
Based on email correspondence between the mother and the day program staff, it doesn’t appear the staff have recognized the extent of the daughter’s concerns. On November 4, a day program manager emailed the mother to say that her daughter “has made a lot of progress and is doing really well. (She) has expressed on several occasions that she enjoys being in program and the activities that we provide.”
There was no acknowledgement in the program manager’s email of the daughter’s health problems.
Three days later, the mother emailed the day program manager to say that medical lab results over the previous year had indicated that there might be a correlation between her daughter’s development of diabetes and her participation in the day program. In that email, the mother wrote that:
(The daughter) has been purchasing candy, cookies and a liter of lemonade frequently at her day program. She has been experiencing fatigue and falling asleep often. It has been a vicious, unhealthy cycle. She needs support to manage her health, rather than her social behavior.
That same day, November 7, the mother brought the group home and day program situation to the attention of Kelly Lawless, the DDS northeast regional director. She wrote:
Direct care staff members have been quick to respond to correspondence and they appear to have good intentions. However, her programming has not met (her) needs and has resulted in a decline in her health and wellness. Her programming has substantially contributed to her development of metabolic syndrome, including diabetes.
Northeast Arc official contends the day program provides activites and exercise
In an email on November 21 to both DDS Commissioner Jane Ryder and to Northeast Arc CEO Jo An Simons, I asked for a response to the mother’s concerns about her daughter’s day program and her request for a new placement for her.
Timothy Brown, chief innovation and strategy officer at Northeast Arc, responded with an email, stating that the daughter had started in a class at her day program called “Health Matters,” and that she had “consistently made healthy eating choices” due to the class, and had not purchased any candy since her diabetes diagnosis.
Brown also contended that the daughter has participated in “structured classes and programming that focus on employment goals and is exploring specific internship opportunities that were identified during these classes where she expressed career interests.” He didn’t identify those goals, and didn’t respond to a follow-up email seeking specifics about the internship opportunities and classes.
Brown also maintained that the daughter has had “ample opportunities for physical exercise during the day.” He said those activities include walking “alongside community members each morning prior to the mall opening”; day trip opportunities outside of the mall, and options during inclement weather for Zumba and aerobics. He also said the daughter attends the YMCA at least two times per week with her housemates, and uses an exercise bike on days she chooses not to go to the Y.
Exercise claims disputed
The mother, however, said in late November that she determined, based on her daughter’s debit card transactions, that she has continued to go to pizza and barbeque wings restaurants in the mall at least once a week, and has continued to eat candy and sugary foods. She also said her daughter told her that the instructor for the Health Matters class had been out for weeks and was out indefinitely. One of two of the provider’s care staff were taking turns running the class, she said.
The mother added that her daughter told her the other activities in the day program primarily consist of computer games such as Jeopardy, Wheel of Fortune, and a game she has repeatedly played called Spent. A reviewer described Spent as a “harsh and often bleak” simulation of a situation in which the players are facing poverty and must figure out how to survive for 30 days on their last $1,000. “It is not appropriate or relevant and I don’t think it is intended to be played repetitively,” the mother told us.
The mother also said that, based on her review of the YMCA records, her daughter has been to the Y 34 times in the past 11 months, which averages out to just over three times a month.
I have not received a response from Ryder to my November 21 email seeking her comment on the situation.
In our view, it is cases like this one that indicate whether a state agency such as DDS is effective in its management and oversight of its provider-run programs. When a provider can’t seem to recognize that a client in its care is experiencing severe health problems as a result of the policies and practices of that agency, the evidence begins to mount that the system is broken.
We would join with the mother in urging DDS to find a new and successful placement for her daughter, preferably in a state-run facility. Given that the daughter’s health is declining, DDS can’t afford to let the situation continue any longer.
Keep fighting for a state operated group placement. From our families experiences I can attest that the state operated group homes provide much better care especially when medical issues are involved. I will pray you have success in getting the services your daughter needs.
our son is in a state operated facility and has been successful there versus a number of different community providers Nebraska
You may want to try this:
https://www.prevention.com/health/health-conditions/a42445274/study-low-carb-diet-helps-type-2-diabetes-management/
Also Google ‘Dr. Sarah Hallberg’ Ted Talk
thanks!
Keep going, you will figure it out!
https://www.facebook.com/1604873403067020/posts/pfbid02JywfPA19Uhz2pPeqi1SeX26Q4kwc8yrgvzxRrLcUWT5uK9hUEbYUm5FzNDdYGhiBl/?app=fbl