Archive

Posts Tagged ‘intellectual disabilities’

Family is shut out of contact with special needs daughter

December 6, 2013 48 comments

Maryann Duzan and other members of her family lost their guardianship of Maryann’s intellectually disabled daughter, Sara, in 2009, based on an admission by Maryann that she once slapped her daughter on the cheek, and the apparent perception that the family has been too aggressive in advocating for her.

As a result, a series of increasingly restrictive limits has been placed by court-appointed guardians and residential providers on family communication with Sara.  Since June, the family has not been allowed to see Sara, who is currently living in a group residence in Westminster, MA, run by a state-funded, corporate provider.

As of late November, the family was prohibited even from talking with Sara over the phone.  The family is afraid she is being subjected to what they consider abusive “restraints” by the group residence staff, but they have no way of determining what is actually going on.

Maryann contends her daughter, who is now 22, has been kept a virtual prisoner in the residence run by Becket Family of Services since late July.  Sara has a condition known as Smith Magenis Syndrome, a genetic disorder characterized by intellectual disability and behavioral outbursts. The family maintains that the use of restraints to control those behaviors actually makes them worse.

According to the family, the restrictions on their contact with Sara and the removal of their guardianship occurred because they called attention to what they termed abusive restraints placed on Sara in previous residential programs in Northfield, NH, and New Marlborough, MA. Their claims about the New Hampshire facility, the Spaulding Youth Center, were corroborated by an attorney for the federally funded Disabilities Rights Center in that state, who found that Sara was repeatedly restrained by staff in the facility between 2008 and 2010.

According to Aaron Ginsberg, the DRC attorney, Sara was often restrained at the Spaulding Youth Center while naked or partially clothed for hours at a time, and male staff were often involved. She frequently suffered bruises and other injuries from what are known as prone restraints, and was subjected to hours of enforced seclusion, Ginsberg stated in an internal DRC memo. In addition, staff at the facility joked about Sara and other residents of the facility on Facebook, Ginsberg wrote.

Sara Duzan (fourth from left) celebrates her birthday with her family in ...  Pictured are (from left)..., her mother Maryann, grandmother...., brother David, father Paul, and ...

Sara Duzan (fourth from left) celebrates a birthday for her grandmother with her family.  Pictured are (from left) Erin Hachey,  Sara’s sister; Maryann, her mother; Virginia Herrity, her grandmother; Sara; David, her brother; Paul, her father; and Tyler, her nephew.  The family has not seen Sara since June and is currently not permitted even to communicate with her by phone.

Ginsberg further noted in the memo, dated November 8, 2010, that Sara’s behavioral outbursts appeared to be largely in response to physical restraints or the threat of their use from the staff at Spaulding.  In his memo, Ginsberg stated: “In most incidents, Sara would not become aggressive until staff approached her or became physical with her.”  Her family believes her aggressiveness in those situations was an attempt to protect herself.

A full investigation of Ginsberg’s findings was apparently never done by the DRC, however.  Now, the family is concerned staff in Sara’s current residence run by Becket Family of Services are once again using excessive restraints on her.

The use of restraints to control behavior has become increasingly controversial.  In an online paper written for the Minnesota Governor’s Council on Developmental Disabilities, attorney David Ferleger maintained that there “is a proven risk of death and other injuries” from the use of restraints, and that “programmatic and planned restraint is not therapeutic or educational.”   He noted that prone restraints involve “the prone positioning of a patient, following which their wrists are secured behind their back, their ankles are tied, and their wrists and ankles are subsequently secured together by pulling the shoulders back and bending the legs towards them.” In a series of 214 cases of people subjected to prone restraints while in agitated delirium, death occurred in nearly 12 percent of the cases, Ferleger stated. Ferleger contended that only vertical person-to-person restraints should be allowed, and only for “a very limited time.”

Excessive restraints as well as communication and visitation restrictions could violate Massachusetts state regulations that require that people with intellectual disabilities receive humane and adequate care and treatment as well as the “least restrictive” level of care, and that they have the right to be visited.  There may be violations as well of regulations governing the use of restraints.

For the Duzan family, all communication with Sara was cut off on November 26, two days before Thanksgiving, when Maryann received an email from attorney Lynn Turner, Sara’s current guardian, announcing that all further contact either by phone or in person was being “suspended indefinitely” and that the police would be called if anyone from the family or “an agent of the family” attempted “to come onto the program,” meaning the Becket Family of Services residence. Turner stated that this cutoff in contact was being instituted “as per agreement between the program staff and me.”

A few months earlier, a document provided to the Duzan family from Sara’s current residential program stated that the family would be allowed to make one 15-minute call a week to Sara, and that no one was allowed to discuss visits home or whether Sara was unhappy at the facility or its treatment of her.  All calls were to be monitored by staff, and the family was to give a two-minute warning to Sara after 13 minutes that the call was coming to an end.   Sara was specifically prohibited from talking to her family about any “dislikes about staff, residence, Becket,” or about restraints. 

Maryann contends the family was allowed seven phone calls with Sara since the end of July, and during five of these phone calls, Sara made statements about being assaulted, punched, restrained and living in poor conditions.   In those instances, Maryann said, the phone was disconnected shortly after Sara began making those claims.

Similar restrictions on family contact were imposed while Sara was at the Spaulding facility.  The latest restrictions on family contact were put into effect despite the fact that a probate court judge in 2010 described the family’s “undeniable love” for Sara.  The family’s apparent problem, as characterized by Norfolk County Probate Judge George Phelan, was that the family as a whole was uncooperative with providers and appointed guardians, and felt “only they know what’s best for Sara.”  Phelan termed the family “ill-suited” for guardianship and “inartful.”

Colleen Lutkevich, COFAR Executive Director, maintains that the Duzan case illustrates the danger a family can face in caring for a disabled loved one if they lose guardianship of the person.  Not only has the Duzan family lost all contact with their daughter, but they say they have spent their life savings on legal costs in their so-far unsuccessful effort to regain their guardianship.  Their legal battle has been a byzantine one that has involved a succession of guardians and even a Special Master in July who is supposed to resolve disputes between the family and Sara’s current guardian.  During this time, the state has paid at least three attorneys to fight the family efforts to regain guardianship, Maryann said.

Andrea Barnes, the Special Master, wrote in July to Maryann that she agreed that “it is important for Sara to know that contact with her family will be a normal part of her life…”  But it does not appear that Barnes has acted on the family’s behalf to restore that family contact. Maryann wrote to Barnes on November 24 to ask her to get Sara out of the current residence because she thought she was being harmed there, but Barnes responded the next day that she had no reason to believe Sara was being harmed.  Barnes promised only that she would visit the residence to check on Sara “sometime in the next few weeks, and will certainly let you know if I have concerns.”

Maryann Duzan and other family members initially gave up their guardianship of Sara in the wake of a December 2009 investigation by the Massachusetts Disabled Persons Protection Commission (DPPC) into allegations of abuse of Sara against the Duzans themselves, including an admitted instance in which Maryann slapped Sara on the cheek.  Maryann contends Sara was browbeaten by the Spaulding staff to implicate her family in abuse.

Maryann said she slapped Sara on one occasion because Sara was acting aggressively while at home and was threatening to throw a radio at her.  She said Sara was acting out because she was due to be returned to Spaulding the next day following a weekend visit home.  Maryann said Sara did not want to go back to the New Hampshire facility because she was being physically abused there, but did not communicate that verbally to her family at the time.

The eventual DPPC report noted that aside from the slap by Maryann, the allegations of beatings of Sara by one or more members of the family were all the result of a statement given on one occasion by Sara to staff at Spaulding.  The report concluded that the DPPC could not substantiate the allegations of abuse other than the slap by Maryann, and that Sara had never spoken negatively of any of her family members until the single occasion on Sept. 1, 2009. 

While the abuse allegations against the family were under investigation, Maryann and her husband, Paul, agreed on the advice of their then attorney to temporarily relinquish their guardianship of Sara.  The DPPC then filed numerous motions for co-guardianship arrangements in probate court that would limit the family’s involvement with their daughter. In October 2010, Judge Phelan ruled that none of the family members were suitable to be either guardians or co-guardians, and that Daniel Smith, the executive director of the Arc of Greater Fall River, should be Sara’s sole guardian.  Phelan noted in his ruling that Smith had served as guardian for 24 other persons.

The major concern Phelan raised in his ruling regarding the family was not any alleged abuse by Maryann or other family members, but the difficulty that provider staff, guardians, attorneys and others allegedly had in dealing with the family as a whole.  But despite the judge’s criticism of the family for acting as if they knew best about Sara’s treatment, the federal Developmental Disabilities Assistance and Bill of Rights Act states that families shall be the “primary decision-makers” in the care of their loved ones with developmental disabilities.

Meanwhile, in September 2009, allegations of excessive restraints used by Spaulding were reported by the Duzans to the Massachusetts DPPC.   Maryann contends the family has tried for four years to report abuse and neglect of their daughter to the state.  She says she sent graphic photos of injuries of Sara while at Spaulding to the DPPC’s deputy general counsel.

But, unlike the attorney for the New Hampshire DRC, no one from the Massachusetts DPPC investigated the family’s claims of abuse at Spaulding, Maryann and other family members maintain.  “They (the DPPC) have made it clear they simply don’t care (about the alleged abuse of Sara by Spaulding staff),” Maryann’s son David, who was temporarily a co-guardian of Sara, stated in a detailed timeline that he wrote about Sara’s treatment from 2006 through 2010.

In June 2011, the Duzans’ new attorney, Michael Turner, alleged the use of excessive restraints on Sara at the Kolbourne School in New Marlborough, MA, where Sara was sent after Spaulding. Turner’s motion alleged that Smith did nothing about either the alleged abuse at Kolbourne or the previous alleged abuse at Spaulding, and that Smith cut off the family’s contact with Sara while she was at Kolbourne. Turner then proposed his wife, Lynne, as Sara’s new guardian.  The family wanted other “options” for guardianship examined, but that apparently never happened.

In December 2011, Smith stepped down as Sara’s guardian and the Duzans agreed on Turner’s advice to accept Lynne Turner as Sara’s sole guardian and to sign a stipulation in probate court that they would never sue the DPPC, DDS, Smith, or their previous state-appointed attorney, George Marlette.  They further agreed to sign a stipulation that no family member would even apply for guardianship of Sara for five years.  Maryann said the family felt forced into signing the agreement to hold the parties harmless out of a fear that the family would never see Sara again otherwise.  To avoid the appearance of a conflict of interest, Michael Turner stepped down at that point as the family’s attorney.

Today, the family considers Lynn Turner to be acting contrary to their and Sara’s best interests because she has upheld the Becket program’s restrictions on their communication with Sara. Once again, the family is unable to contact Sara, despite the assessment by a probate judge that they are a loving family to her.  And once again, they fear Sara is being subjected to abusive restraints.

“All we want is Sara safely back home, never to be hurt again, and state agencies to stop retaliating against our family,” Maryann says.

We share the Duzans’ concerns about the situation Sara may be facing in her current residence. We hope the probate court will act quickly to return her to her home.  We urge people to call their legislators to ask for their help in getting Sara back home.  And we think this case merits an independent legislative investigation of all of its aspects.

The phone numbers for the Legislature’s Children, Families, and Persons with Disabilities Committee are (617) 722-1572 (Senate staff), and (617) 722-2011 (House staff).  You can email the co-chairs of the Committee:  Senator Michael Barrett at Mike.Barrett@masenate.gov and Representative Kay Khan at Kay.Khan@mahouse.gov.

In addition, you can contact: Governor Patrick constituent services at constituent.services@state.ma.us; DDS Commissioner Elin Howe at elin.howe@state.ma.us; and Attorney General Martha Coakley at ago@state.ma.us.

 

A ‘thank you’ from Patrick Costa

December 5, 2013 4 comments

A funeral mass was held November 26  for Patrick Costa, a longtime resident of the Fernald Developmental Center, who died on November 19 at the age of 49.  Below is a letter written in Patrick’s voice by his guardian, Ann Witham, who read it at the mass for Patrick.  Ann is a former Fernald employee who agreed to be Patrick’s guardian after his mother died.  She also managed the Fernald chapel for the Rev. Bill Leonard, who has been the pastor at St. Jude Parish in Waltham in addition to his Fernald Chaplin duties.

My Dear Family and Friends,

During my time on earth, I could not talk; I never learned how to read or write or spell; or how to type or use a computer.  But my life has changed.  I’m with God now and as long as He’s ok with it, I can do almost anything, including writing this thank you letter.

The first thing I want to say is a big thank you to all the folks at Fernald for caring for me for almost forty years.  They gave me the best they could and I am truly grateful for their efforts.  It was not easy for me to leave that home, but in the end, it turned out to be a very good thing for me.  When the time came for me to move here to the Wrentham Developmental Center, you went to a lot of trouble to make sure that Heffron “B” was really ready for my friends and me.  You even took extra time to fix the few little things that somehow got overlooked the first time around.

Patrick Costa

Patrick Costa

My friends and I were warmly welcomed into our new home.  It seemed as though everyone involved in our care – from direct care staff to clinicians and everyone in between, took the time to get to know each of us as individuals and to learn first-hand what each of us liked and disliked.  You saw abilities and possibilities, not just disabilities; potential, not just limitations.

You found out that I liked to walk and made sure that I got to join a walking program and participate in Special Olympics where I won a medal.  How proud and happy that made me feel!  I really liked that special green suit I wore for the occasion and showing off the medal to my friends.  I enjoyed going to the pool and you made sure that I had enough swimming trunks for these outings. I am so grateful for your supporting me in all my athletic endeavors, and for finding alternative activities when exercise was no longer possible for me.

Thank you for taking the time to make sure I ate my meals slowly so I would not choke.  Sometimes it was a real challenge just to be sure I chewed before I swallowed, or, to make sure I did not snitch something from another’s plate.  I must admit though, I did manage to succeed a couple of times and thoroughly enjoyed it.

You learned to read the visual ways and sounds I used to tell you what I wanted or what was wrong.  Somehow, you knew that when there was a lot of commotion in the apartment, I would need to “get away from it all;” and spend some quiet time in my room.  You even made sure that I had a special chair to use for relaxation.

Going to Adult Ed was a favorite activity for me.  I was thrilled when I could sign a card with assistance.  When I could no longer get to the program, you made it happen right in my apartment.  That’s what the world would call “really great customer service.”

Van trips were also very special to me.  I especially liked going to the restaurants that went the extra mile and texturized our food so we could eat our meals there.  Thank you for taking the time to plan and organize those special “nights on the town.”

To all who stayed with me while I was in the hospital and at The May Center and back at my apartment, I owe so much.  Your presence gave me more comfort than I can tell.  It was wonderful to wake up and see a familiar face there with me and to hear your voices reassuring me that all was well.  You knew the severity of my condition, but never let it discourage you from being upbeat with me.  Special thanks go to Keith, my long-time friend and companion.  During the last days of my life, Keith watched out for me, protecting me from “strangers” he did not know, keeping things where he thought they should be and making sure staff was always paying attention to me.   A special thank you to new friends from Steward Hospice.  Their care, compassion and concern for me as a person went far beyond what I expected.   Even Keith could not prevent their welcomed presence in my life during my final days.

Mark, I know distance and family matters made it very difficult for you and Beth to travel to visit.  I know you were in constant contact throughout the years, and that the distance did not separate me from your thoughts and affection.   I tried so hard to wait for you, but Jesus came to bring me to my forever home and I had to go with him.  Please take care of yourself.  Your wife and your children need you.

I owe a very special debt of gratitude to Jim Devin for bringing Ann, and sometimes Marilyn, to visit with me.  Jim and Ann, I knew you were both there shortly before I died, and I felt your love and took it with me when Jesus came to bring me home.  And, last but not least, thank you to Father Bill for coming here on his day off to lead you all in prayer.  Father Bill, I’m going to ask God to bless your ministry and to let you have calm seas, fair skies and a string of “keepers” for all the coming fishing seasons.

My friends, I hope you do not grieve too long for me.  My spirit lives on and is oh so happy now with Jesus and my mother and all my friends and relatives who went before me.  I will never forget you and will always pray for you.  I pray God will wipe the tears from your eyes and hearts and that his peace will console, bless and always be with each of you.

With much love and gratitude,

Patrick

DDS challenge to mother’s guardianship of her son dismissed

November 25, 2013 1 comment

The mother of an intellectually disabled man, who has been locked in a dispute with the Department of Developmental Services for several years over her son’s medical needs, will be able to remain as his guardian, according to a probate court agreement reached last week.

A Middlesex County Probate Court judge last week signed off on the dismissal of a year-long effort by the DDS to remove Patricia Feeley as guardian of her 27-year-old son, Michael.  DDS had filed a petition in probate court in November 2012 to appoint James Feld, an attorney, as Michael’s guardian, even though Feld had never met Michael.

The DDS’s long-running dispute with Feeley, a COFAR Board member, has centered around Feeley’s contention that Michael, who has type 1 diabetes, needs a residential care setting with 24-hour nursing.  Feeley has been trying for years to find a suitable residential placement for her son, who has lived at home his entire life.  DDS has taken the position that Michael doesn’t need round-the-clock nursing.

DDS signed a stipulation to dismiss its challenge to Feeley’s guardianship during a probate court hearing last week, according to Stephen Sheehy, an attorney representing Feeley. Sheehy said he believed that DDS “came to the hearing prepared to dismiss the case because they recognized that Pat (Feeley) was doing a good job as Michael’s guardian and this was not a proper forum to deal with a dispute over a (residential) placement.”

In filing its original petition to remove Feeley as guardian, DDS had argued that Feeley was not acting in her son’s best interest in rejecting residential placements for him that the Department had offered.  The Department’s petition also cited  excessive “clutter” in Feeley’s home as a reason for removing Feeley as guardian.  However, DDS did not allege any neglect or abuse on Feeley’s part, and even acknowledged she is devoted to her son.

Feeley said this week that she was glad of the dismissal of the guardianship challenge and hopeful “that somehow Michael will be offered a placement appropriate to his needs.  He has been waiting for six years.”  She added that, “I hope DDS will realize and take this (dismissal of the guardianship petition) as an affirmation that Michael’s needs are Michael’s needs. That’s what this is all about, not what DDS wants.”

Feeley added that DDS has never produced a clinical document to back up its contention that Michael does not need 24-hour nursing care.  Feeley, however, did provide the court with a May 28, 2010 letter from a physician at Children’s Hospital in Boston, who wrote that Michael’s blood glucose spikes at times “for no apparent reason,” and that “it is not possible to predict when that might occur.”  The doctor’s assessment continued that, “A nurse needs to be present and able to attend to Michael’s needs at any time to avoid a delay in Mike receiving appropriate medical intervention.”

Feeley said her son requires as many as seven injections of insulin per day.  He also has a profound intellectual disability, is non-verbal and is unable to dress or bathe himself.  Feeley, 65, who works as a part-time clinical lab technician and is a certified nurse assistant, currently administers the injections herself, monitors Michael’s blood glucose, and personally provides all other care at home for him.  Michael’s extensive care needs have prevented her from working full time.

We are happy that DDS has finally realized it brought its dispute with Pat Feeley over the care of her son to the wrong judicial forum.  Why DDS subjected Feeley to a frightening, year-long battle to retain guardianship and why the Department subjected taxpayers to the expense of an unnecessary probate court battle are troubling questions.

Based on what is apparently the only clinical document submitted in the case — the letter from the Children’s Hospital doctor — Michael does appear to need 24-hour nursing.   We hope the outcome of this guardianship challenge finally spurs DDS to do the right thing and find a placement appropriate to Michael’s needs.

The system continues to fail the most vulnerable in the Templeton case

November 19, 2013 Leave a comment

It seems that as events unfold in the wake of the alleged fatal assault of an intellectually disabled man at the Templeton Developmental Center in September, the system continues to fail everyone it was intended to protect.

Last week, Anthony Remillard was found competent to stand trial in connection with the death of  Dennis Perry whom Remillard allegedly assaulted while both were in the Templeton Center’s dairy barn.  As of this week, Remillard was being held without bail in the Worcester County House of Corrections.

We’ve already written here a number of times about our concern that Remillard was inappropriately placed at Templeton due to his apparently high level of dangerousness, and was not under sufficiently close supervision while there.  However, given that Remillard is himself intellectually disabled, it seems to us that the Worcester County House of Corrections is an equally inappropriate place for this 22-year-old man.

Bonnie Valade is the mother of Tony Welcome, a Templeton resident who has himself had some previous scrapes with the criminal justice system and spent time at the same county jail facility now housing Anthony Remillard.  She maintains that jail was wrong for her son, who she said was abused there, and will be equally wrong for Remillard.  In an email, Valade had this to say:

My son was badly beaten (at the Worcester County House of Corrections)  simply because he put his arm around an inmate saying ‘hello.’  The other inmates took everything we brought for him including his radio. He was sexually abused.  They put him in a suicide cell just to keep him away from the population.  If anyone knows about a suicide cell…it contains nothing not even clothes, only their underwear.

People with intellectual disabilities need clinical and other therapeutic services.  They don’t tend to receive those services when they end up in correctional facilities.  And they do end up in correctional facilities more often, it seems, than people of normal intelligence.

A recent article on the website Disabled-World.com notes that intellectually disabled people constitute “a small but growing percentage” of suspects and offenders within the American criminal justice system. While they comprise between 2 and 3 percent of the general population in the country, they represent between 4 and 10 percent of the population in prison and an even larger portion of the population in juvenile facilities and jails.

Intellectually disabled people like Anthony Remillard and Tony Welcome need to be in places that provide them with supportive supervision, structure, and security.  In many key respects, prisons provide none of those things.  It’s hard to imagine that the behavioral issues that Anthony Remillard apparently had that led to the alleged assault on Dennis Perry are going to be dealt with in a positive way where he is now.  And the fact that he has been found competent by a judge to stand trial in the alleged fatal assault means he could end up in prison for the rest of his life.

As has been pointed out by others in this case, the system failed Dennis Perry, and now it is failing Anthony Remillard.  In both cases, it does not appear that sufficient supportive supervision, structure, or security were or are being provided.

Unfortunately, we see the potential for more of these systemic failures as Massachusetts and many other states continue to cut staffing at facilities such as Templeton, which currently meet strict federal standards of care.  We’ve asked for a legislative hearing to examine, among other things, whether a major phase-down in staffing at Templeton in recent years resulted in the apparent failure to adequately supervise Remillard there.

Templeton and countless other facilities like it are being closed around the country in the name of deinstitutionalization.  The closure process has not resulted in better lives for everyone, however.  We are creating a largely privatized system of care in this country that in many respects provides less supervision, structure, and security than before.

Even the most ardent proponents of privatized, community-based care acknowledge that the community system isn’t working very well.  In a recent op-ed piece, the president of the Massachusetts Association of Developmental Disabilities Providers, referred to the “funding disaster that has governed private programs” that now serve most of the people with disabilities in the state.   The quality of the care provided by these private programs reflects that funding disaster.  The programs are rife with poorly trained and poorly compensated staff and with the consequent problem of abuse and neglect.

And what then happens to the Anthony Remillard’s who are caught up in a system of care that cannot adequately serve them or protect others from them?  In more and more instances, they end up in a much worse institutional system — the prison system.

It is now well known that deinstitutionalization of the mentally ill since the 1960’s has led to a continued increase in the population of mentally ill people in the nation’s prison system.  We are only starting to realize that the same thing is happening with respect to people with intellectual disabilities.

Compromise bill expands DDS eligibility to some, but not all people with developmental disabilities

October 28, 2013 8 comments

After months of negotiations with a limited group of advocates for the developmentally disabled, key state legislators have approved a draft of a bill intended to expand services to people who are not currently eligible for help from the Department of Developmental Services.

The bill (H. 3715) would expand eligibility for residential and other services to people with what is now referred to as Autism Spectrum Disorder, although the legislation uses the older term “autism” to describe the group.  The bill also specifically mentions Prader-Willi Syndrome – a disability often associated with autism.

While a step forward, the compromise bill appears to leave out a number of other disabilities that are eligible for similar services in many other states, such as cerebral palsy, epilepsy, spina bifida, and traumatic brain injury, and cognitive impairments such as Williams Syndrome.

We understand top Patrick administration officials were concerned about the price tag in including a large list of developmental disabilities in the bill.  State law currently restricts eligibility for services from DDS to persons having an “intellectual disability” as measured by an IQ score of approximately 70 or below.  Intellectual disabilities are considered a subset of developmental disabilities.

Currently, thousands of people in the state are developmentally disabled in that they are unable to care for themselves or otherwise function adequately in society; yet, they are ineligible for services from the state because they do not have an intellectual disability.

The new bill, which appears to have been hastily drafted, would extend DDS services to people with developmental disabilities,  but would restrict the definition of a developmental disability to “a severe, chronic disability of an individual 5 years of age or older that is attributable to a mental or physical impairment’s (sic) resulting from intellectual disability, Autism or Prader-Eilli (the spelling should be Prader-Willi) Syndrome.”   The bill was approved on October 21 by the Children, Families, and Persons with Disabilities Committee and sent to the Health Care Financing Committee.

Colleen Lutkevich, COFAR Executive Director, cited, as an example of someone who would fall through the cracks of the new legislation, a person with normal intelligence but with a severe level of cerebral palsy that precludes him or her from being able to feed or toilet himself or herself.  Under the compromise bill, that person would not be considered developmentally disabled and therefore would still not qualify for services.  “Services are needed at all levels for people with all types of disabilities,” Lutkevich said.

A previous draft of the bill had not specified any developmental disabilities in expanding DDS eligibility, but had defined developmental disability as a condition “attributable to a mental or physical impairment,” which results in “substantial functional limitations” in three or more “major life activities.”  Those activities included self-care, receptive and expressive language, learning, mobility, self-direction, a capacity for independent living, and economic self-sufficiency.

That previous draft would have included people with disabilities such as cerebral palsy if those disabilities were severe enough to cause substantial functional limitations in three or more major life activities.  As such, the previous draft would have “focused pragmatically on the challenges faced by the individual and their family, and avoided leaving people to fall between the cracks,” as one advocate described it.

We are hopeful that the Legislature and the administration will find a way to include in this bill all those who are in need of DDS services.  Many other states have figured out ways to avoid leaving vulnerable people behind, and Massachusetts should be among those innovative states.

A disappointing update on sheltered workshops in Massachusetts

October 4, 2013 2 comments

In a post the other day, I suggested that state Department of Developmental Services Commissioner Elin Howe talk to family members of sheltered workshop participants, who maintain the programs have provided their loved ones with valuable social and skill-building activities.

But no such luck.

In an email notice send out yesterday, Howe announced that no new DDS clients will be referred to sheltered workshops in Massachusetts after January 1.  As we feared, this is the beginning of the end of this valuable program in the state.

Sheltered workshops provide opportunities for developmentally disabled people to do assembly work and other tasks in group settings, usually for small amounts of pay.  But for Commissioner Howe and other opponents of sheltered workshops, these programs are politically incorrect.   Sheltered workshops, they argue, “segregate” disabled people from their non-disabled peers, apparently in just the same way schools and businesses in the South segregated blacks in the days before the Civil Rights movement.

Howe said sheltered workshop providers have been instructed to develop plans to “transition their workshop services to more integrated employment options,” meaning the plan is to place all workshop participants in the mainstream workforce.

Let’s leave aside the question whether it is really valid or fair to compare intellectually disabled people, whose guardians voluntarily place them in programs that provide them with work activities, to blacks who were forced until the 1960’s in this country to drink at separate water fountains and go to separate schools from whites.

For now, I would simply argue that we’re skeptical that closing programs that provide work activities for people with developmental services will somehow increase their overall employment opportunities.

I wonder if Commissioner Howe has thoroughly reviewed a 2011 report by the University of Massachusetts Boston on trends in employment prospects for people with developmental disabilities.

While the UMass report does appear to be biased against sheltered workshops, it notes that there has been relatively little movement so far toward mainstream employment of people with intellectual disabilities from sheltered workshops around the country.  The report cites as reasons for this lack of movement, “staff resistance, family resistance, and funding structures that do not adequately support community-based services for people with high support needs.”

In other words, families like and want their loved ones to stay in sheltered workshops; and it takes money to place people with Intellectual and developmental disabilities into mainstream jobs with the types of supervision and support they need.  And we’ve seen, that money isn’t there.  All of this seems to raise questions about the wisdom of DDS’s decision to stop all new referrals to sheltered workshops.

In fact, one of the outcomes of closing sheltered workshops, which appears to be highlighted in the UMass report, is that many, if not most, of the people who are participating in sheltered workshops will end up being transferred to what are called “non-work” settings if those workshops are closed.  Non-work settings, also known as day programs for people with developmental disabilities, may or may not provide them with meaningful work activities to do.

The UMass report noted that in 2010, there were 3,700 people with Intellectual disabilities in sheltered workshops in Massachusetts and about 3,500 people in “integrated employment.” However, there were about 9,500 people in “non-work” settings.   The report stated that: “State, county, and local IDD (intellectual and developmental disabilities) dollars are increasingly being spent on CBNW (Community-based Non-Work) services and not integrated employment.”

So, our concern is that when all sheltered workshop programs are ultimately closed in Massachusetts, most of the former participants will end up in day programs where they do nothing and get no pay at all.  And even if many of these people are placed in so-called integrated employment, the outcomes may not all be good.  Howe certainly didn’t consult the Buonomo’s about their son’s disappointing experience working at Walmart, for instance.

Given all that, it was amusing to read in her email that Howe remains “strongly committed to working with all of our stakeholders” in ultimately closing all remaining sheltered workshops in the state.  I don’t recall her asking for our opinion on it or acknowledging the opinions of most family members of sheltered workshop participants.

Sheltered workshops under fire in Massachusetts

September 30, 2013 8 comments

Paul Buonomo enjoys his job stuffing envelopes, collating papers and carrying out other tasks in a program in Danvers known as a sheltered workshop.

His parents, Doris and Joe Buonomo, maintain that the workshop, run by Heritage Industries, is the best such program Paul has ever been in.

But in the wake of a national debate over the political correctness of sheltered workshop programs for people with developmental disabilities, programs such as Paul’s may soon be phased out.  Here in Massachusetts, the Department of Developmental Services is reviewing its policies regarding sheltered workshops and has invited state-funded providers into a working group to determine what the future will be for the programs.

Sheltered workshops provide opportunities for developmentally disabled people to do assembly work and other tasks, usually for a small amount of pay, in group settings.  The charge of political incorrectness stems from the fact that the workers are not participating in the nation’s mainstream workforce and are therefore allegedly being “segregated” from non-disabled people.  In many – perhaps in most – cases they also receive sub-minimum wages.

The charge that sheltered workshops promote segregation and inadequate pay to disabled people is being leveled not only by a number of advocacy groups, but by government agencies, including the federal Department of Justice and the National Council on Disability.

These are the same advocates and agencies, by the way, that have long opposed all forms of congregate care for the developmentally disabled.

But supporters of sheltered workshops, many of whom are family members of the workshop participants, argue that these programs provide their loved ones with fulfilling work and skill-building activities, and that if the programs were eliminated, there would often be nothing to take their place.

The Buonomos, for example, don’t believe their son, who is 60 and has moderate intellectual disability, is at all segregated or placed at a disadvantage because he isn’t receiving a competitive wage in a mainstream workforce setting.  Heritage Industries provides Paul with a check every two weeks that varies from $2 to $10, depending on the amount of work Paul does, according to Joe Buonomo.  It’s not much money, Joe says, but Paul lives in a state-operated group home and doesn’t personally have to deal with financial pressures that would necessitate a job paying a competitive wage.

Gail Orzechowski, whose sister, Carol Chunglo, 73, participates in a sheltered workshop in Orange operated by Interface Precision Benchworks, maintains that the program has “opened up her (Carol’s) world.  I don’t know how they can say she’s segregated,” she adds.

The  Arc of Massachusetts has stated that the impetus in Massachusetts to reconsider its sheltered workshop policies stems from litigation in Rhode Island and Oregon, which has involved the Justice Department.

In the Rhode Island case, a service provider was accused of improperly “segregating” developmentally disabled persons in a sheltered workshop and paying them sub-minimum wages.  Under a settlement of the case, clients in sheltered workshops will be switched to supervised mainstream employment, which implies the end of sheltered workshops in that state.

Following the June settlement in Rhode Island, a Department of Justice official maintained that from that point on, every developmentally disabled client in the state’s sheltered workshops would receive “real jobs with real wages,” and would no longer be subject to “the tyranny of segregation.”

It’s not quite clear to us, though, how providing real jobs at real wages to all disabled people will actually happen.  Like the Buonomos and Gail Orzechowski, we also don’t buy the charge of segregation when it comes sheltered workshops, in particular.   Doris Buonomo says she hopes DDS will listen to outside voices, particularly those of parents like her and her husband Joe, who believe the workshops have made a positive difference in their loved ones’ lives.  Thurs far, we have heard only that DDS has invited the Massachusetts Association of Developmental Disabilities Providers and the Massachusetts Arc to participate in the working group that is reviewing the Department’s sheltered workshop policies.  Both of those organizations have taken positions against the workshops (here and here).

Meanwhile, family members and other supporters of sheltered workshops around the country are fighting the tide of closures of sheltered workshop programs.  They contend the Justice Department and other opponents of the workshops are fighting an ideological war, but are offering no viable alternatives.

In New Jersey, the state Legislature stepped in this summer to prevent a plan by the state to close the state’s sheltered workshops.  The New Jersey plan to defund the workshops met with opposition from advocates and from program participants and their families around the state, according to The Burlington County Times.

An online petition filed by Missouri AID, an advocacy organization for the intellectually disabled, states that sheltered workshops “are the only places where some individuals can work and function as productive members of the community.”  The petition, which garnered 3,092 signatures, adds that:

There are countless horror stories about individuals who have tried supported (mainstream) employment, and they fell in with the wrong group of individuals, were taken advantage of, sent to prison, or ended up walking the streets alone. Sheltered workshops throughout the U. S. provide a safe environment for adults with (intellectual and developmental disabilities) to work, interact with their peers, and gain a sense of accomplishment…

The Missouri AID petition adds that “We should be creating more employment opportunities for people with disabilities – not eliminating options.”

While the idea that people with developmental disabilities should work alongside non-disabled peers and earn competitive wages is good in theory, it doesn’t always work in practice, Doris Bunomo notes.  In Paul’s case, for instance, a job at Walmart ended badly for Paul even though he had gotten good performance evaluations there for a job stocking shelves, and had even earned a promotion.

Doris said Paul had been working at Walmart for a year, but an incident occurred one day in which he got “upset,” leading to a situation in which he was lectured by the manager and threatened with being fired.  Doris said a support staff person for Paul did not follow an agreed-upon protocol between the  residence and Walmart, and Paul did not work there again.  Doris maintains that many people with developmental disabilities can work in professional or business settings with careful supervision, but that is not always possible.

“I think he’s very pleased where he is,” Joe Buonomo says of his son, adding that while Paul primarily interacts with other developmentally disabled people in his sheltered workshop, there are many opportunities in his life to meet people who are not disabled.

”I don’t think he (Paul) feels restricted in any way,” Joe maintains.  In addition to the many community-based functions that Paul attends via his group home, he often helps Doris deliver books and other items to their local library and church.  Also, given Paul’s lifelong love of trains, his parents have also often taken him to the freight train terminal in South Portland, Maine, where he has “made a ton of friends with the workmen” over the years, Joe says.

Orzechowski says the workshop that employs her sister Carol has helped teach her how to function socially.  “Her eating habits and her other social habits have improved, and she’s developed friendships since she’s been in the program,” Orzechowski says of her sister, who she describes as having a severe level of intellectual disability.  Carol, she says, also has many opportunities to interact with people in the community, including vacations that she has taken with money earned from her workshop program.

It’s far from clear what may happen in Massachusetts regarding sheltered workshops.   We certainly hope that whatever is done, DDS will first consult with the families involved such as the Buonomos and Gail Orzechowski.  If DDS does listen to those people, the Department will find a way to keep these valuable sheltered workshop programs running.

Bedford group home resident’s injuries raise disturbing questions

September 16, 2013 2 comments

We don’t yet know what happened to cause the serious injuries suffered in late August by Paul Stanizzi, a resident of a group home for the intellectually disabled in Bedford.

The incident is currently under investigation by the Bedford Police Department, which, as of Friday, was declining comment on the matter and would not even issue a police report.  But whether Stanizzi was assaulted or whether the injuries were somehow self-inflected or an accident, the incident raises serious questions about the operation and management of the residence.

Fox25 TV news reported on September 9 that Stanizzi, who is non-verbal, was found lying on the floor in his room by a staff worker at the group home, which is run by the Edinburg Center, Inc., a nonprofit provider that is funded by the state Department of Developmental Services.

After Paul Stanizzi’s mother was called by the staff worker, the family rushed to a hospital and found Paul unresponsive in a hospital bed.  His brother Joe pointed out to Fox25 reporter Mike Beaudet that Paul had a black eye,  a bloody nose, bruises on his fingers, scratches on his arm, what appeared to be fingerprint bruises on his arms, two larger bruises on his leg, a cut on his knee, and other abrasions.

Despite all that, the hospital was about to discharge Paul, Beaudet reported.  But when Paul’s father tried to raise him from the bed, his head flopped down.  An MRI subsequently revealed damage to the vertebrae around his neck. According to the Fox report, medical records noted “possible recent injury” as a cause.  The doctors performed emergency surgery. It is apparently not clear whether Paul, who remains in the hospital, has been permanently paralyzed from that injury.

In a statement, Edinburg CEO Ellen Attaliades told Fox25 she could not discuss Stanizzi’s medical condition because of patient confidentiality rules.  But she added, “Unfortunately there are instances when individuals with severe developmental disabilities can injure themselves through their own physical actions. To allege abuse without any evidence and without considering all factors is both wrong and unjust to his devoted caregivers.”

It’s certainly true that developmentally disabled persons, like anyone else, can injure themselves, although the extent of Paul Stanizzi’s injuries in this case points strongly toward the possibility of abuse.  But even if it turns out to be the case that Paul Stanizzi somehow injured himself, what does that then say about the staffing and management of the group home?  If Attaliades believes that the scenario under which Paul injured himself lets her agency and the residence entirely off the hook in this case, we think she’s mistaken.

DDS regulations require that facilities funded for the care of the developmentally disabled must be safe environments.  We hope the Bedford police and the Disabled Persons Protection Commission are asking questions to determine just how safe this particular environment could have been.  Did Paul haven a history of self-injurious behavior?  If so, how carefully was he supervised?  How long was he lying on the floor before he was discovered?  Was he physically capable of injuring himself to the extent described?  Were background checks done on all of the staff there?  What kind of training was provided to the staff?

An online DDS licensing report on the Edinburg Center states that Edinburg’s two-year license to operate residential group homes was being “deferred” because of problems with medication administration.  Other problems were noted in the report that required a 60-day follow-up by DDS, although there were no references to specific problems with abuse or neglect there.

The licensure report also stated that Edinburg had been experiencing growth since 2008 and yet was “dealing with economic decline and its ongoing impact on agency services.”  The report added that the provider had lost clinical and emergency services and yet had opened two new 5-person homes in FY 2010.  It seems strange that a provider would be cutting services and yet opening new homes at the same time.

Opening new facilities at the same time that services are being cut may indicate that this provider may be stretched thin on its staffing, or was stretched thin as of December 2010. (The posted licensure report was dated December 2010, which would make it about 9 months out of date.  DDS licensure reports and operating licenses are valid for two years, meaning that a new report should have been posted on the website in December 2012.  We have pointed out in the past that many of the licensure reports posted on the DDS website are out of date.)

Fox25 stated that Attaliades, the Edinburg CEO, told them that Paul Stanizzi is considered “part of The Edinburg Center family and his health and well-being are their primary concern.” We hope that is the case, but a thorough investigation is the only way to be at all certain of that.

We and others have long pointed out that care in widely dispersed group homes in this and other states is very difficult to monitor.  Earlier this year, U.S. Senator Chris Murphy of Connecticut called for a federal investigation “into the alarming number of deaths and cases of abuse of developmentally disabled individuals in group homes.”   Unfortunately, the Massachusetts DDS, in particular, does not appear to have placed a high priority on the safety of the provider-run care system that the Department funds.

The community-based, group home system in Massachusetts needs to be more tightly overseen, and the experience of Paul Stanizzi is one more in a long line of disturbing incidents that demonstrate that need.

The story of a remarkable woman

September 10, 2013 2 comments

I never met Joanna Bezubka, who lived at the Fernald Developmental Center for 39 years and then spent the final seven years of her life in a state-operated group home in Lynnfield.

But after reading “Joanna, God’s Special Child,” a new memoir by George Mavridis, I feel I got to know her well enough that I’m sad I never will meet her in the flesh.  That’s because Mavridis, Joanna’s cousin and co-guardian, has written an account of her life that makes you realize what a truly remarkable person she was — filled with charm and humor and an independent spirit.

These are qualities that many of us would not think possible in a person with a profound intellectual disability whose vocabulary was limited to about 50 words and a small range of vocal inflections.  Joanna, who had Down syndrome and the cognitive ability of a two-year-old child, died in January 2012 at the age of 60 after developing Alzheimer’s disease.

Given its title, some people might think this book comes at its subject from a religious or sentimental perspective.  It is neither of those.  As Mavridis explains, “God’s special children” was a description given in the 1950’s by Richard Cardinal Cushing, Roman Catholic Archbishop of Boston, to individuals with mental retardation, now known as intellectual or developmental disability.

It’s not that Mavridis rejects Cardinal Cushing’s description.  Mavridis is in fact a practicing Catholic who pushed hard to allow Joanna to continue attending Mass every Sunday at the Chapel of the Holy Innocents at Fernald, long after she had left the facility as a resident.  It’s that Mavridis goes so much further than Cardinal Cushing’s description in telling us who Joanna really was.

George Mavridis and Joanna Bezubka celebrate her birthday

George Mavridis and Joanna Bezubka celebrate her 59th birthday

Mavridis, a former president of COFAR and The Fernald League, has chronicled Joanna’s life down to some of the smallest details in a matter-of-fact, journalistic style that is all the more compelling because it deals honestly with the major issues of her life,  even some of the most difficult and painful episodes. Those episodes include a sexual assault of Joanna, allegedly by staff in a group home in which she lived, and Mavridis’s dogged pursuit of the investigation of the incident.

It’s important to note that Mavridis is a strong defender of a comprehensive system of care for people with developmental disabilities, including the availability of federally regulated Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs) for those, like Joanna, who need or needed them.  Mavridis has been a central figure in the still-ongoing effort to keep Fernald open.   He is also a member of the legislative committee of the VOR, a national advocacy organization for the developmentally disabled, which, like COFAR, supports ICF-level care.  As a VOR legislative committee member, Mavridis organizes visits with the health aides of the members of the New England congressional delegation.

But the purpose of Mavridis’s book is not to make a statement on one side or the other in the debate over institutional versus community care.  It is rather to chronicle a person’s life and to demonstrate the necessity and effectiveness of advocacy for the most vulnerable among us.

If you are the guardian or family member of a developmentally disabled person and you are looking for help in how to cope and advocate on their behalf, I think this book will be very helpful.  I think it would also be helpful to legislators and others who seek a better understanding both of who developmentally disabled people are and what is involved in caring and advocating for them.

If nothing else, this book provides a detailed set of reasons for the importance of a provision in federal law, which states that family members should be seen as the “primary decision-makers” in caring for intellectually disabled persons.  As Joanna’s co-guardian and the family member most intimately involved in her life, Mavridis was an a far better position to understand her needs and to act in her best interest than the bureaucrats and even some other advocates who often claimed to know what was best for her.

There is one small but telling incident in the book that illustrates that point particularly well.  Joanna was a diminutive woman — only four-foot, four inches tall — and Mavridis bought all her clothes for her.  He recounts that he would occasionally hear disapproving comments from Department of Developmental Services staff members that the Disney characters on the sneakers he had bought for her were not appropriate for a woman her age.  “I would respond,” he writes, “that they should go to a shoe store and look for a woman’s size 2 1/2 pump with a low heel and buy them for Joanna.”

Joanna’s mother died during a heart operation in 1966 when Joanna was 15 years old.  As a result, Mavridis’s mother, Stella, became her guardian, and Mavridis himself became co-guardian in 1991.  In later years, Joanna’s brother Ronald Bezubka became a co-guardian along with Mavridis; but as Ronald was living in England, Mavridis remained in charge.  In Joanna’s later years, Mavridis would visit her twice a week at her group home and take her to his home in Peabody every Saturday.

Throughout, Joanna’s story is told with warmth and humor, largely because of Mavridis’s clear and obvious love for his cousin.  He writes that his mother “always said that I was the brother that a girl feels she could hold under her thumb, and Joanna never let me up.”

We learn, for instance, that although Joanna’s teeth had been removed and her food had to be ground, she was a “gourmet,” who “ate very slowly and savored every morsel.”  At Fernald, the staff “served her first and picked up her dishes last, so she had time to enjoy her meals.”  She also liked to sip coffee all day long and always had a cup with her, which she invariably perched on the edge of the table.  “Many times my mother would move it back, away from the edge,” Mavridis writes, “but Joanna wold move it back with a stern look.”

One of Joanna’s favorite games with people was to ask them to cuff her shirt sleeves.  “After you did it, Joanna would straighten the sleeves and ask you to cuff them again.  This exercise became endless.”  Her favorite activities also included playing with Lego toys and tearing paper into ever smaller pieces.  Mavridis found he was obliged to carry a supply of both Lego pieces and pieces of paper with him because Joanna liked to hand out both as tokens of friendship to anyone who came by her.

Playing the shirt-sleeve cuffing game

Playing the shirt-sleeve cuffing game

Mavridis also speaks frankly about his own quadruple coronary artery bypass operation, which happened in the same year as the sexual assault, and the effect of his temporary incapacitation on Joanna.  He also details Joanna’s physical and mental decline beginning in 2008, when she developed Alzheimer’s Disease, a condition which afflicts nearly all people with Down syndrome as they age.

Mavridis relates how sad it was for him to watch Joanna’s limited ability to communicate disappear in her final four years.  She stopped tearing paper and she stopped playing with Legos and handing them out as tokens.  Mavridis nevertheless was determined to make her life as comfortable as possible and bought special lift equipment for her as well as a special hospital bed and recliner.

"I bet I blinked first," Mavridis says of this photo.

“I bet I blinked first,” Mavridis says of this photo.

Near the start of his book, Mavridis includes a short article by a writer, Emily Perl Kingsley, about what parents go through when they first learn that their child is intellectually disabled.  “When you’re going to have a baby, it’s like planning a fabulous vacation trip to Italy,” Kingsley writes.  Instead, the plane lands in Holland.

“The important thing is that they haven’t taken you to a horrible place,” Kingsley continues.  “It’s just a different place, so you must go out and buy new guide books and you must learn a whole new language…but after you’ve been there for a while…you begin to notice that Holland has windmills; Holland has tulips; Holland even has Rembrandts.”

“Joanna, God’s Special Child” is the story of a wonderful journey to Holland for Mavridis and his family, and of their discovery of the windmills, tulips, and Rembrandts there.

We can do better than the final DDS budget for current fiscal year

July 8, 2013 4 comments

As we start the 2014 fiscal year, there was some good news, but mostly bad news for people with intellectual disabilities and their families in the final budget produced by the Legislature last week .

The bad news is that funding for state-operated care fared poorly in the final budget bill as it emerged from a House/Senate Conference Committee on June 30.  As explained below, this has negative implications for corporate-run, community-based care as well.

The good news is that there will at least be a hearing on the so-called ‘Real Lives’ bill, if that flawed piece of legislation ever gets enacted.  The Conference Committee did not approve the Real Lives language, which we have objected to and which had been quietly inserted into the budget bill by its prime sponsor.

The Real Lives bill’s supporters will have to go back to pushing the measure (H. 151) through the normal legislative process.  The proposed legislation, which is still in the Children and Families Committee, still hasn’t been scheduled for a hearing, according to the legislative website.

The budget Conference Committee did accept the Senate’s proposed funding level for the state-operated group home line item, which is slightly better news than had the Committee accepted the House funding level.  As a result, the state-operated group home line item was cut by only $1.5 million from the governor’s budget, rather than $1.96 million, as the House had previously voted.

The Conference Committee’s proposed funding for the state-operated residences is $9.1 million higher than in the just-ended fiscal year, but it apparently still represents a shortfall in the amount needed, according to the Department of Developmental Services.  That is largely because state-operated group homes appear to be the preferred care setting for a large number of residents of developmental centers that have been marked for closure.

The Conference Committee also decided to cut the DDS administrative line item (which funds service coordinators) by $700,000 from the governor’s budget and cut the developmental center line item by close to $400,000 from the governor’s budget.  Both of those cuts are bad news for state-operated care, and they will adversely affect the quality of community-based care.

First, service coordinators are state employees who make sure that DDS clients receiving both state and privately provided care are getting the right services.  For years, their funding has been cut even as their caseloads have grown.  Service coordinators are integral to maintaining the quality of care in the DDS community-based system.  DDS Commissioner Elin Howe has referred to service coordinators as “the heart and soul of our agency.”

Secondly, while many proponents of community-based care may think that the continuing cuts to funding of the developmental centers is good news for the community system, the opposite may in fact be true.  We’ve noted repeatedly that the money “saved” in phasing down and closing the developmental centers has not been diverted into most community-based accounts as the administration had promised.

The result is that as the developmental centers are closed, their residents are being moved into community-based care ahead, in many cases, of people who have been waiting for years for residential placements.  And those former developmental center residents appear to be absorbing whatever additional funding has been put into the community-based system as the developmental centers are phased down.

For example, we understand that the last residents of the Glavin Regional Center in Shrewsbury were moved in recent weeks into state-operated and corporate-operated group homes in the surrounding area.  Those former Glavin residents were clearly placed ahead of other developmentally disabled persons in the Shrewsbury-Worcester area waiting for residential care.

Some community-based line items did fare slightly better in the Legislature’s budget than they had in the governor’s budget plan last January.  The Conference Committee approved a $2.8 million increase over the governor’s budget for adult family supports, a $1 million increase in autism services, and a $500,000 increase in Turning 22.  The Committee accepted the governor’s budget amounts for both community transportation and day programs.  The Senate had cut the governor’s proposals for both of those line items by $500,000.

The Conference Committee, however, cut the community residential line item by $13 million from the governor’s budget proposal.  That still represents a $59 million increase over the just-ended fiscal year.  But it appears the community system would need a far larger increase than that to begin to address the serious shortfall in care and services that the system is plagued with.

In sum, the administration and the Legislature have chosen with this budget to continue the expansion of corporate care of the disabled without adequate funding or oversight.

The state is continuing to close small, strategically located developmental centers, which provide the most intensive and heavily monitored levels of care, and to scatter the residents to inadequately monitored group homes.   At the same time, the decision has been made to continue to cut funding for one of the few sources of monitoring left of the privatized system — the service coordinators.

And that privatized, community-based system itself continues to be underfunded, contravening the administration’s promised “Community First” agenda.  It would seem that a state that prides itself on the care it provides its most vulnerable citizens could and should do better than that.