Like DDS, DPH failing to provide records concerning admissions to Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children
In a move that feels like “déjà vu all over again,” the Department of Public Health (DPH) is defying a state order in failing to respond to our public records request for information related to admissions at Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children.
We first requested data regarding Pappas on July 28, 2026, more than 100 days ago. Massachusetts Public Records Law requires state agency records access officers to respond to public records requests within 10 business days. To date, we have neither received any records nor a timeline for future receipt.
This public records struggle follows a months-long battle with the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) for records involving admissions at the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs). DDS produced ICF census records nearly three months after our request. However, we are currently appealing DDS’s decision to withhold their ICF admissions policy, which they have declined to release to us since at least February 2025, despite numerous public records requests.
The repeated delays and denials by state agencies in furnishing public records may reflect a lack of transparency within the Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS), the umbrella secretariat housing both DDS and DPH.
After appealing DPH’s lack of response, the supervisor of records issued a determination letter on September 14 ordering DPH to provide us with a response to our request consistent with Public Records Law and its regulations within 10 business days. That 10-day period expired on September 28. We received no communication from DPH between September 14 and September 28.
After notifying the Public Records Division of DPH’s non-adherence to the determination letter, the Division followed up with a “compliance notice” to DPH on October 23 that DPH has yet to respond to as well. This same non-compliance appeal process took place regarding the records we had sought from DDS.
It is unclear why both DPH and DDS appear to be treating the Public Records Law as optional.
The data we are seeking concerning Pappas includes the following information from Fiscal Year 2020 to the present:
- Documents containing policies developed by DPH regarding admissions to Pappas[;]
- Data sufficient to show the number of referrals, requests for placement, admission applications, admission denials, and waiting list placements (if any), together with aggregate reasons for denial, if tracked[;]
- Data sufficient to show the monthly (or, if unavailable, annual) patient census, licensed bed capacity, operational bed capacity, vacancies or the number of vacant beds, admissions, and discharges[;]
- Documents concerning any plans to consolidate or close Pappas, including, but not limited to, plans to increase or decrease the number of beds[;]
- Any and all written materials provided to family members and guardians from Fiscal Year 2020 through the present that contain information on the process for admissions to Pappas and/or available options for such placements.
Seeking data due to a decline in the patient population
We are requesting this data because — as with the Wrentham and Hogan ICFs — we are concerned about the future viability of Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children.
In January 2025, Governor Maura Healey announced plans to close Pappas, a state-run rehabilitation hospital for children and young adults with multiple disabilities. Although Healey later paused the closure decision, concerns about restrictive admissions criteria, lack of new long-term admissions, and continued discharges have raised suspicions about a quiet closure of Pappas, as we previously reported.
The situation at Pappas has striking parallels to the trajectory of the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs), which are state-run developmental centers for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities. The census at Wrentham has dropped from 323 residents in fiscal year 2012 to 130 today, while the census at Hogan has decreased from 155 to 82 during that same time frame. The state-operated group home network, moreover, has also experienced a declining census over time.
These trends open wider questions about the fate of critical state-run services in the Commonwealth amid privatization.
“Miscommunication” blamed
After we wrote to the public records division on September 29 regarding DPH’s lack of response to the determination letter, Helen Rush-Lloyd, the DPH records access officer, emailed us on October 2, stating that DPH was continuing to process our public records request. She said, “There was a miscommunication that my colleagues thought you had received the responsive records. Now they have the records and are reviewing them and hope to have them to you soon.”
That day, we responded to Rush-Lloyd, asking when DPH would provide the requested records in compliance with the supervisor of records’ determination, Rush-Lloyd’s October 2 email did not provide a specific timeframe beyond an indication that her colleagues “hope” to offer the records soon.
To date, we have not received any further response from Rush-Lloyd or from anyone else in the Department. We followed up with Rush-Loyd on October 22, requesting a response to our October 2 email to no avail.
After our repeated outreach to the Public Records Division about DPH’s lack of compliance with the supervisor of records’ determination letter, a Public Records attorney sent a compliance notice to Rush-Lloyd on October 23 asking that DPH provide “an estimated date” by which they plan to comply with the September 14 order.
As of today, more than three months have passed since our original request, with limited communication, no production of records, and no adequate explanation from DPH for the ongoing delay.
Concerns about transparency in EOHHS
We find it unacceptable that multiple state agencies are apparently choosing to bypass the law while the public is left with limited recourse, especially when the information in question impacts the lives of some of the Commonwealth’s most vulnerable people. We will continue pursuing this public records request in our efforts to preserve essential state resources.

When one has nothing to hide, one has no problem turning over records. Transparency in this state is lacking on all levels. Those who fail to comply should step down or be forced to step down.
Has COFAR sought help from a state or federal legislator? If not, have you written an OpEd? When I was in the military assigned to MA, the state violated my son’s rights. I found that communicating with the state was like trying to talk with a concrete wall. the same was true with the Lincoln school district.
This is unfortunately consistent with my own experience trying to obtain information about how decisions affecting people with intellectual and developmental disabilities are actually made.
One example involves Day Habilitation. MassHealth regulations require a Service Needs Assessment that determines an individual’s functional level, needs, and strengths and makes specific recommendations based on those needs. Yet I have been unable to obtain documentation demonstrating that this required assessment process was actually carried out for my profoundly disabled, nonverbal son, who also has an inflammatory bowel disease.
That is why these public records battles are so important. When families and advocates ask for the policies, assessments, criteria, and data underlying government decisions, we should be able to see how those decisions are being made. When those records cannot be produced, it becomes impossible to determine whether objective criteria are actually being applied.
The parallels among Pappas, Wrentham and Hogan, and the individual service system are troubling. Before services are reduced, placements denied, or state resources allowed to disappear through declining census, the public deserves to know what objective needs assessments and decision-making criteria are being used.
Transparency should not require months of requests, appeals, and repeated attempts simply to obtain records that explain how these decisions are made.