Archive
Like DDS, DPH failing to provide records concerning admissions to Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children
In a move that feels like “déjà vu all over again,” the Department of Public Health (DPH) is defying a state order in failing to respond to our public records request for information related to admissions at Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children.
We first requested data regarding Pappas on July 28, 2026, more than 100 days ago. Massachusetts Public Records Law requires state agency records access officers to respond to public records requests within 10 business days. To date, we have neither received any records nor a timeline for future receipt.
This public records struggle follows a months-long battle with the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) for records involving admissions at the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs). DDS produced ICF census records nearly three months after our request. However, we are currently appealing DDS’s decision to withhold their ICF admissions policy, which they have declined to release to us since at least February 2025, despite numerous public records requests.
The repeated delays and denials by state agencies in furnishing public records may reflect a lack of transparency within the Executive Office of Health and Human Services (EOHHS), the umbrella secretariat housing both DDS and DPH.
After appealing DPH’s lack of response, the supervisor of records issued a determination letter on September 14 ordering DPH to provide us with a response to our request consistent with Public Records Law and its regulations within 10 business days. That 10-day period expired on September 28. We received no communication from DPH between September 14 and September 28.
After notifying the Public Records Division of DPH’s non-adherence to the determination letter, the Division followed up with a “compliance notice” to DPH on October 23 that DPH has yet to respond to as well. This same non-compliance appeal process took place regarding the records we had sought from DDS.
It is unclear why both DPH and DDS appear to be treating the Public Records Law as optional.
The data we are seeking concerning Pappas includes the following information from Fiscal Year 2020 to the present:
- Documents containing policies developed by DPH regarding admissions to Pappas[;]
- Data sufficient to show the number of referrals, requests for placement, admission applications, admission denials, and waiting list placements (if any), together with aggregate reasons for denial, if tracked[;]
- Data sufficient to show the monthly (or, if unavailable, annual) patient census, licensed bed capacity, operational bed capacity, vacancies or the number of vacant beds, admissions, and discharges[;]
- Documents concerning any plans to consolidate or close Pappas, including, but not limited to, plans to increase or decrease the number of beds[;]
- Any and all written materials provided to family members and guardians from Fiscal Year 2020 through the present that contain information on the process for admissions to Pappas and/or available options for such placements.
Seeking data due to a decline in the patient population
We are requesting this data because — as with the Wrentham and Hogan ICFs — we are concerned about the future viability of Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children.
In January 2025, Governor Maura Healey announced plans to close Pappas, a state-run rehabilitation hospital for children and young adults with multiple disabilities. Although Healey later paused the closure decision, concerns about restrictive admissions criteria, lack of new long-term admissions, and continued discharges have raised suspicions about a quiet closure of Pappas, as we previously reported.
The situation at Pappas has striking parallels to the trajectory of the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs), which are state-run developmental centers for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities. The census at Wrentham has dropped from 323 residents in fiscal year 2012 to 130 today, while the census at Hogan has decreased from 155 to 82 during that same time frame. The state-operated group home network, moreover, has also experienced a declining census over time.
These trends open wider questions about the fate of critical state-run services in the Commonwealth amid privatization.
“Miscommunication” blamed
After we wrote to the public records division on September 29 regarding DPH’s lack of response to the determination letter, Helen Rush-Lloyd, the DPH records access officer, emailed us on October 2, stating that DPH was continuing to process our public records request. She said, “There was a miscommunication that my colleagues thought you had received the responsive records. Now they have the records and are reviewing them and hope to have them to you soon.”
That day, we responded to Rush-Lloyd, asking when DPH would provide the requested records in compliance with the supervisor of records’ determination, Rush-Lloyd’s October 2 email did not provide a specific timeframe beyond an indication that her colleagues “hope” to offer the records soon.
To date, we have not received any further response from Rush-Lloyd or from anyone else in the Department. We followed up with Rush-Loyd on October 22, requesting a response to our October 2 email to no avail.
After our repeated outreach to the Public Records Division about DPH’s lack of compliance with the supervisor of records’ determination letter, a Public Records attorney sent a compliance notice to Rush-Lloyd on October 23 asking that DPH provide “an estimated date” by which they plan to comply with the September 14 order.
As of today, more than three months have passed since our original request, with limited communication, no production of records, and no adequate explanation from DPH for the ongoing delay.
Concerns about transparency in EOHHS
We find it unacceptable that multiple state agencies are apparently choosing to bypass the law while the public is left with limited recourse, especially when the information in question impacts the lives of some of the Commonwealth’s most vulnerable people. We will continue pursuing this public records request in our efforts to preserve essential state resources.
Like the Wrentham and Hogan Centers, Pappas remains open, but is its future truly secure?
In a striking parallel to the uncertainty surrounding the future of the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs), uncertainty lingers over the fate of the Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children in Canton.
Governor Maura Healey has stated that she has paused her proposed closure of Pappas in the wake of strong opposition to the closure from unions and other advocates, including COFAR. The governor has made no formal statements regarding the future of Wrentham or Hogan, but we believe the fates of all three facilities are connected.
Back in June, we joined self-advocates, families, and staff members urging legislators to protect the hospital-school during a public hearing of a Special Legislative Commission tasked with investigating the long-term direction of the facility.
Many speakers offered testimony, but one message was apparent: concerns about restrictive admissions criteria, lack of new long-term admissions, and ongoing discharges have raised suspicions about a quiet closure of Pappas. The same dynamics are true involving Wrentham and Hogan.
Although comments during the legislative hearing appeared to indicate that the Healey administration has changed its course and is now embracing a collaborative approach to revitalizing the campus, it is unclear how this response has materialized in the months following the committee hearing.
With reportedly 12 long-term patients and no short-term respite patients today, 28 beds remain unfilled at Pappas in the face of statewide need. The question remains: is the closure of Pappas truly paused?
The situation at Pappas has staggering parallels to the trajectory of the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs), state-run developmental centers for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities. The census at Wrentham has dropped from 323 residents in fiscal year 2012 to 132 today, while the census at Hogan has decreased from 155 to 82 during that same time frame.
As COFAR has previously reported, the administration is also allowing the Wrentham and Hogan Centers to die by attrition by denying admissions to all but a handful of applicants in recent years while their censuses steadily drop. Families report that they are not informed of ICF options or have their placement requests rejected. If these trends continue, closure of these facilities is inevitable.
During the legislative committee hearing, COFAR voiced concerns about the restrictive admissions process at Pappas and shared our experience working with families facing similar barriers at Wrentham and Hogan, encouraging commissioners to re-examine the policies that shape access to care.
The pattern opens broader concerns about the future of essential state-run services in Massachusetts.
Background on proposed closure of Pappas
Originally founded in 1904, Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children, previously known as the Massachusetts Hospital School, provides medical care and educational, rehabilitative, and therapeutic services for children and young adults with multiple disabilities ages 7 to 22+.
The 166-acre campus boasts a variety of unique features specifically designed to accommodate the needs of individuals with disabilities, ranging from covered walkways for wheelchair maneuvering, a pool with ramps, and a rehabilitation engineering department creating customized equipment and assistive technology for residents. Moreover, the facility offers patients extensive recreational programming, including horseback riding, adaptive sports, and creative arts, as well as a bowling alley, electronic gaming room, and reservoir pond for waterfront activities.
In January 2025, Governor Healey announced in her FY ‘26 budget proposal that she planned to close the Canton facility due to “aging infrastructure” as detailed by a 2023 feasibility study administered by the state. A number of children would be moved to Western Massachusetts Hospital in Westfield, over 100 miles away, where a 25-bed, modernized pediatric wing would be established in the predominantly adult hospital. She said the decision was merely a “redirecting of services of care” and would save the state 31 million dollars.
These savings amount to 0.10% of the state’s 30.4+ billion dollar Executive Office of Health and Human Service’s (EOHHS) FY ‘25 budget.
An email from Pappas admin to families specified that other students could be transferred to alternate placements such as hospitals, nursing homes, group homes, or family homes. The Department of Public Health (DPH) reported that the facility at the time had 36 patients, over half of whom were over the age of 18 and already pending discharge to “more appropriate” settings.
DPH Commissioner Robbie Goldstein justified the decision by stating, “What we know is that many of those children actually could be better cared for, more safely cared for, more compassionately cared for at home.”
Healey’s plan faced public backlash before she visited Pappas for the first time in February and ultimately paused the closure later that month, first seeking to elicit feedback from stakeholders. Families and staff members emphasized the vital nature of the specialized services provided by Pappas and expressed concern that patients would be separated from their loved ones and Pappas’ 225 employees who might not be able to relocate two hours away. Many also vocalized frustration that they were never consulted about the decision.
State House leadership echoed this surprise, with Speaker of the House Ronald Mariano asserting that the closure plans came “out of the blue” and he “didn’t know anything about it.”
Now, Pappas can neither be closed nor have patient services reduced until the Special Legislative Commission, established by an amendment filed by Canton Representative William Galvin to the FY ’26 budget and subsequently extended, submits a report with its findings and recommendations by the end of the calendar year 2027. The Commission is led by Senator William Driscoll and Representative Marjorie Decker, co-chairs of the Joint Committee on Public Health. Other members include state officials, executive leaders, Pappas staff, and the parent of a current Pappas patient.
This Commission effectively builds on the work of the Pappas Working Group (PWG) previously convened by the governor. The PWG developed an October 2025 report assessing options for the campus in the wake of the closure pause, such as “re-imagining” the campus by expanding services, pursuing phased investments on campus, maintaining the status quo, lowering the level of care, and closing the facility.
Special Legislative Commission hearing
The Pappas Special Legislative Commission hosted its June 17 public hearing to gather personal accounts and other information that would guide its study into the facility’s future. The hearing lasted over four hours and united a diverse group of families, self-advocates, staff members, and public officials, nearly all, reiterating their observations of what appeared to be a de facto closure of Pappas. COFAR also testified during this hearing in support of maintaining the facility.

Commissioners seeking concrete steps to protect Pappas
In opening statements, several Commissioners urged for substantive actions to secure Pappas’ future.
Representative Galvin stated he was “very frustrated and angry with this administration and the way they have handled this situation.” He explained that he filed an amendment establishing the Special Legislative Commission in response to the Governor’s Pappas Working Group, which he believed was created to support the administration’s closure decision. Given the new commission’s formation, he expected the administration to begin examining possibilities for facility repairs following years of underfunding and offer ideas for possible partnerships with providers but received “nothing” from them. He said he hopes that the Commissioners will develop a concrete plan for directing money into Pappas as a result of these meetings.
Similarly, Senator Paul Feeney, whose district includes Pappas, commented that he was “a little bit talked out on this.” He acknowledged the value of the Commission but stressed that it is time to “start putting our money where our mouth is and making it happen” through funding decisions to reimagine Pappas.
Closure by attrition
The urgency for these substantive changes was illuminated by the declining census referenced across hearing testimonies.
Kim Daley, a special education teacher at Pappas and member of the Commission, described how a “clear shift” has taken place since the January 2025 closure announcement in her opening statement. She stated there has been “a noticeable and sustained focus on discharging patients while admissions appear to be effectively blocked and have not been approached with any comparable urgency.”
Jim Durkin, the Legislative Director of AFSCME Council 93, similarly identified a disconnect between the administration’s official position and the messaging staff conveyed to staff. “You hear one message from the top, and then when you get down on the ground, it’s an entirely different message down there and we keep hearing the same excuse: ‘It just hasn’t trickled down yet; we’re open for business.’ Again, I call B.S.,” he said.

Senator Paul Feeney cited a monthly report from the Department of Public Health showcasing a census decline from 35 to 21, with only 2 long-term admissions and 18 discharges between January 2025 and March 2026. All other admissions are occurring on a respite basis, with stays typically lasting no more than a couple of weeks. SEIU Local 509 President David Foley later clarified that the 2 intakes were actually students who were discharged within 2 months.
Speakers attributed this lack of new admissions to the Commonwealth’s narrow definition and application of “hospital level of care” criteria. Commissioner Nicole Friel, whose daughter currently attends Pappas, noted that she was told her daughter “would no longer meet the criteria for admission had she applied currently,” despite having the same medical condition. Friel questioned whether “we are somehow defining things differently now than we did in the past.”
Need for high-acuity care for children statewide
Massachusetts Nurses Association (MNA) President Katie Murphy asserted that these developments have transpired even with a “larger need” in the Commonwealth as reflected in the report issued by the Governor’s own Pappas Working Group. This report found that there are over 12,000 children in the state with medical complexity and under 2,000 beds available in the Commonwealth, leaving considerable children “stuck” in acute care hospitals over time.


“Needs of Special Needs Population” per Governor’s Pappas Working Group Final Report
Student regression in alternate settings
Speakers detailed how many students discharged from Pappas have been moved to settings unable to meet their needs despite objections from their families, teachers, and clinical team.
Caitlin Horrigan, a Pappas teacher for over a decade, highlighted student regression post-discharge. She recounted one student who shifted from independently navigating Pappas’ campus to using a wheelchair with a 1-1 support staffer in public school and suffering a medical event requiring extended hospitalization and surgery within one month of discharge from Pappas. Other students, she said, transferred to residential programs without comparable vocational opportunities, lost key IEP services, or were denied admissions from other residential schools because of their medical complexity. “Is this ‘the community’ DPH is talking about?… They deserve a least restrictive environment for them. I have yet to see a student ‘more compassionately’ or ‘better cared for’ when they left Pappas,” she exclaimed.
Jennifer Ford, a former Pappas educator, stressed the day-to-day realities many families with medically complex loved ones face. She said, “After hearing the DPH Commissioner claim that this population is cared for more compassionately at home and better served in the community, I’ve learned firsthand it’s just not that simple. These families are the toughest, most self-sacrificing people out there; the majority of the families I serve are single mothers, often with multiple children living in cramped apartments without wheelchair lifts or elevators. It is common for a parent to physically lift a grown child out of their wheelchair and carry them up multiple flights of stairs… but what about her quality of life?”
Numerous speakers underscored that Pappas is a vibrant community in its own right. Pappas graduate John Mariani recalled in his testimony that he “didn’t feel like [he] fit in with public school” but at Pappas, finally “belonged [and] fit in.”
Response from DPH Commissioner Robbie Goldstein
DPH Commissioner Robbie Goldstein, however, maintained that the facility is operating regularly. He said, “Let me be clear in this statement: we fully support keeping Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital open and stable while this Commission conducts its vital work. The Governor’s budget fully funded continued operations of Pappas. That means we are continuing admissions and appropriate discharges, backfilling staff positions as needed, avoiding layoffs, avoiding service reductions as the process to design the best future and the right future for caring for medically complex children in the state proceeds.”
He explained that the facility is facing “challenges,” most notably, physical infrastructural issues that limit the facility’s ability to serve children with higher medical and behavioral support needs, such as individuals who require mechanical ventilation or 24/7 monitoring.
Nevertheless, he noted that leadership has “not waited” to address some of these difficulties. He stated they hired a psychiatric nurse practitioner for the first time, staff developed marketing materials to broaden outreach, and they strengthened referral networks through site visits with various hospitals.
When questioned by Chair Driscoll about how the facility appears to be “depopulated” over time, Commissioner Goldstein replied that he “can’t speak to what prior administrations have done.” He stated that during his oversight, the DPH has adhered to hospital regulations that require patients to meet “a hospital level of care.” Failure to adhere to this standard, he said, would put the state in violation of its Medicaid contracts, risking fines and other penalties from the federal government. He acknowledged that monthly admissions have historically decreased but attributed this to the “reality of the legal structure we exist in as a hospital and the physical limitations of the plant.”
In response to staff reports that they have been informed of a future closure, Commissioner Goldstein insisted, “From the top of the Department of Public Health, we have been very clear that the hospital remains open,” and individuals who say otherwise “may not be listening to leadership” and current admissions procedures.
Executive commitment to “turning a new page” for Pappas
Commissioner Goldstein later acknowledged that the administration is supportive of a collaborative approach to facilitating investments in the Pappas campus. He stated, “Now we are in a place where we have accepted that there are solvable problems there and we need to come together to figure out how to get the right investment into that campus so that it can be safe for children to be there” while also identifying solutions for the other vulnerable children statewide.
Chair Decker expressed surprise at the apparent shift from considering whether the facility should be saved to discussing how to revitalize the campus with executive collaboration but applauded it as a “welcoming conversation” that would alter how the Commission moves forward, aiming to invite members of the administration to future meetings.
She added she hopes to see “layers” of action from the administration, including identifying necessary baseline renovations, providing the Commission data regarding admissions and denials, and communicating to staff that the facility is open so information will “trickle down to the bureaucracy.”
Federal support for Pappas
The legislative hearing even drew federal participation, with Congressman Stephen Lynch, whose district is home to Pappas, testifying before the Commission.
Congressman Lynch praised Pappas as “irreplaceable” and a “national model for pediatric rehabilitation care.” He voiced frustration that federal assistance was not previously sought to maintain the facility, stating, “The leadership at Pappas has never asked me for money, never asked me for an earmark… that bothers me that we are not robustly and vigorously fighting for every single dollar we can get for that facility… We could do this building by building.” He vowed to “pursue every available federal resource to help the Commonwealth find a path forward that does not require the closing of this facility,” embracing a phased investment approach to redeveloping Pappas.
“Dear God, if we can’t help these people, what the hell are we doing… we need to step up and do the right thing,” he remarked.
Reality today
In the months following the legislative committee hearing, it is unclear how the Healey administration has changed its course to ensure Pappas’ longevity, as discussed during the hearing, although there have been some successes in the legislature.
Legislative developments
Through the legislative process, the final FY ‘27 budget, enacted July 9, fully funded the facility and extended the appointment of the Pappas Special Legislative Commission for another calendar year. However, additional efforts to obtain long-term capital investment in the facility have had mixed results. In the House version of the July economic development bill (H.5562), Representative Galvin filed an amendment proposing the establishment of a capital grant program to upgrade the Pappas infrastructure and the creation of a five-year capital plan. This amendment was not incorporated in the final version of the House bill.
In the Senate, meanwhile, an amendment filed by Senator Feeney seeking 2 million dollars for Pappas facility repairs and upgrades to increase admissions was adopted as part of the Senate’s economic development bill (S.3178) later that month. The bill is currently in conference committee. If advanced, the funding could help address longstanding infrastructure issues at Pappas, including the pool, which remains in disrepair, restoring student access to critical water therapies. Current alterations include repairing the clocktower and refacing and painting the pergolas.
Limited long-term admissions and ongoing discharges
There is limited evidence of meaningful progress in increasing long-term admissions.
In light of Commissioner Goldstein’s comments that Pappas is open and accepting admissions, members of the Pappas community took to social media to share information about the application process. On July 1, they celebrated that Pappas had received its first long-term admission in almost a year. That month, the exterior Pappas signage featured new postage “Accepting Admissions,” seemingly opening the doors to new students.
In an interview with Michael Poirier, a former Pappas student and staff member for decades, he revealed that the reality on the ground is much different. When Pappas students began the new school year, they were joined by only 11 long-term patients and 4 short-term respite patients, with multiple students slated for discharge in the first few weeks. 29 empty beds remained. He said at the time the July admission reflected the only new admission after the Special Legislative Commission hearing, with 6 discharges occurring since that time.
Today, there are reportedly 12 long-term patients and no short-term respite patients, with 28 empty beds.
This lack of new admissions has continued even in the face of demand for placement. Poirier said that the administration has “absolutely not” changed course to work collaboratively with the Special Legislative Commission as discussed during the hearing or achieve meaningful increases in admissions as aligned with Commissioner Goldstein’s claim that Pappas is open and accepting new admissions. He said it took until the beginning of October for the DPH to provide the Special Legislative Commission the information it requested during the June hearing regarding patient referrals and denials. He added approximately 20 long-term admission referrals have been denied over the past year, even when the admissions committee voted to accept the patients, since the decisions were overruled by Commissioner Goldstein and his team at the DPH and Pappas. This includes an individual who has reportedly been in an acute care hospital in Boston for over 100 days and is recognized by Boston physicians as meeting the criteria for “hospital level of care.”
While the Governor’s team has stated that there is a commitment to keeping Pappas open as the Special Legislative Commission continues its work, he said, “Indecision and failure to make important meaningful decisions that will meet the needs of those Pappas serves, could serve, or will keep the doors open undermines the Governor’s public commitment and is nonsense.” He urged infrastructural investments to improve existing buildings, opening the outpatient program, and a “true plan” to diversify the campus and meet the needs of people of all abilities across state agencies as the path forward. He noted a plan to reopen outpatient services was previously submitted to DPH leadership in May; however, no action appears to have been taken by the Department.
Healey administration assuring commitment to reimagining Pappas
During her remarks at AFSCME Council 93 Legislative Conference in September, Governor Healey reiterated the administration’s collaborative approach to reimagining the facility. She said, “I know people haven’t been happy about Pappas. Pappas was underinvested in for decades, okay. Now I think we’re in a good place; we’re having the conversations, we’re thinking about, with your input and involvement, how do we reimagine Pappas… We are going to do something good there, I can promise you that.”
In early October, a member of DPH leadership reportedly recognized the need for new admissions to Pappas and apologized to staff for some of the challenges occurring throughout the year. Soon after, the Chief Medical Officer (CMO) for DPH hospitals visited Pappas alongside other EOHHS officials.
In an October 10 weekly update from Representative Decker, she highlighted that she met with the legislative delegation and Healey administration officials to discuss the future of Pappas as part of the Special Legislative Commission’s ongoing work.
The Press Offices of Governor Healey, the Executive Office of Health and Human Services, and the Department of Public Health did not respond to my request for comment on the status of Pappas.
Similar circumstances at Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs)
Ambiguity surrounding the status of Pappas also clouds the prospects of other state-run facilities. Although formal closure plans have yet to be announced, the future of Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs) for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities remains fraught.
Families indicate that they are not informed of the existence of these facilities and are denied placement. It is only through media coverage or attorney involvement that we have seen the few accepted individuals gain entry.
Meanwhile, the census continues to decrease. Wrentham’s census dropped from 323 residents in fiscal year 2012 to 132 today, while Hogan’s declined from 155 residents to 82 during the same period.
Even if Pappas is ultimately preserved, the loss of Wrentham, Hogan, and the similarly dwindling state-operated group home network will eliminate other high-acuity adult care options for Pappas patients aging out of the system.
COFAR raised concerns about admission policy restraints at Pappas and detailed similar impediments at Wrentham and Hogan during the Special Legislative Commission hearing, asking commissioners to review the policies impacting care access. The overlap presents wider concerns about the fate of important state-run services in the Commonwealth.
While we are working in the legislature to preserve Wrentham and Hogan and are interested in exploring the establishment of a legislative commission dedicated to their future, it appears that the efficacy of such a commission will depend on the administration’s willingness to collaborate.
Continued advocacy to protect Pappas, Wrentham, and Hogan
We are urging our members to contact their state legislators and encourage them to call for the Legislative Commission to begin working on a long-term plan for the future of Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children.
Also, please ask the Commission to consider investigating restrictive admissions to other key state-run placements for people with disabilities, including the Hogan Regional Center and Wrentham Developmental Center. The patterns across these placements point to larger issues within the EOHHS involving patient access to care.
Let the Commission know that even if Pappas survives, the question remains where its residents will go when they turn 22 and age out of that care. If Wrentham and Hogan are closed, a critical option for residential care will have been lost permanently not only to those Pappas residents but to all persons with intellectual and developmental disabilities in Massachusetts.
You can find your state legislators here: https://malegislature.gov/Search/FindMyLegislator
Additionally, we ask that you consider contacting Governor Healey’s office and encourage her administration to work collaboratively with the Legislative Commission by taking tangible steps to protect all of these valuable assets.
You can contact Governor Healey’s office at (617) 725-4005.
Advocacy continues following Senate budget decision on Wrentham and Hogan amendments
Our two budget amendments aimed at preserving the Wrentham and Hogan Intermediate Care Facilities (ICFs) for adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities ultimately did not move forward in the Massachusetts state Senate during its debate last month on the Fiscal Year 2027 state budget.
This outcome was not unique; out of the 1,158 amendments filed to the Senate budget, more than half were either withdrawn or rejected. Senate Ways and Means Committee Chair Michael Rodrigues previously indicated that “there is not a ton of room for amendments” this budget cycle.
The amendments, 411 and 555, filed by Senate Minority Leader Bruce Tarr and Senator Becca Rausch, would have altogether affirmed a right to care at Wrentham and Hogan for persons found to be eligible for ICF-level care, required the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) to report on its efforts to offer these settings as a choice for residential care, and protected current ICF residents from involuntary discharge.
In both the House and Senate, the adoption of budget amendments are subject to decisions by the legislative leadership. Most amendments are voted on in bundles, and only a limited number are formally considered by the full chamber. As a result, our amendments were not individually debated or voted on in either chamber.
Our budget language was consistent with federal law and aligned with DDS’ movement toward “self-direction,” which expands the role of individuals and families in the planning and selecting of services.
The Senate results follow our amendment effort in the House. There Representative Marcus Vaughn filed three amendments containing our language (amendments 695, 699, and 703). Although the amendments received the bipartisan support of 19 legislative co-sponsors, they also were not adopted.
Because our amendments did not advance in the House or Senate, our language will not be incorporated into the FY ‘27 state budget. However, we are hopeful that we have laid the groundwork for the reintroduction of our proposed language next year to save the Wrentham and Hogan facilities.
We are pleased that during this year’s budget debates, nearly a quarter of the Senate formally engaged on this issue by either sponsoring or co-sponsoring the amendments. It is encouraging to know that we are spreading awareness across the legislature, which oversees state agencies such as DDS. As noted, we believe this sets the groundwork for future legislative advocacy efforts.
This year marked our first sustained attempt to modify the state budget language.
Senate amendment co-sponsors
We would like to thank Senate Minority Leader Bruce E. Tarr (R, First Essex and Middlesex) and Senator Rebecca L. Rausch (D, Norfolk, Worcester and Middlesex), the principal sponsors of our amendments, along with the following co-sponsors:
Senator Pavel M. Payano, D, First Essex
Senator Jason M. Lewis, D, Fifth Middlesex
Senator John F. Keenan, D, Norfolk and Plymouth
Senator James B. Eldridge, D, Middlesex and Worcester
Senator Nick Collins, D, First Suffolk
Senator William J. Driscoll, Jr., D, Norfolk, Plymouth, and Bristol
Senator Vanna Howard, D, First Middlesex
COFAR member outreach
We additionally would like to thank our COFAR members for their tireless advocacy. Whether emailing or calling their state senators, sharing our posts on social media, or encouraging others to contact their legislators, we were heartened by the outpouring of support. Your help was essential to the progress that we were able to achieve this year. Thank you for sharing your stories and perspective.
Future legislative advocacy efforts
We will work to enact this language again next year since we believe the facilities are in danger of closure.
The Wrentham and Hogan centers offer a high level of federally regulated care for individuals with some of the most profound disabilities. They also provide more than 1,000 jobs for direct care workers, clinicians, medical personnel, and others, according to the latest data available from DDS.
The population at both facilities has decreased significantly, however. Families report that they are not informed of ICF options or have their placement requests rejected. If these trends continue, closure of these facilities is inevitable.
It was only last year that Governor Maura Healey announced the proposed closure of Pappas Rehabilitation Hospital for Children, a state-run residential hospital for children with disabilities that is reportedly now experiencing similar restrictions on admissions. We remain committed to safeguarding essential state-operated services for people with disabilities amid rampant privatization.
We encourage you to continue sharing your perspective with legislators to keep attention on this issue. If you are interested in participating in future legislative advocacy efforts, please contact us at info@cofar.org. Together we can preserve the Wrentham and Hogan centers.
DDS and group home deny responsibility for month-long family hospital visitation ban
The Department of Developmental Services (DDS) and a department-funded group home provider are denying responsibility for having blocked a group home resident’s family from visiting him at Brigham and Women’s Hospital for more than a month, starting in January.
The hospital is not commenting on the matter and has been unresponsive to numerous attempts by COFAR to inquire on behalf of the family about the justification for the blocked visitation. The hospital has even declined to clarify its general visitation policies.
Meanwhile, the resident’s DDS-funded guardian and the Seven Hills Foundation, the group home provider, appear to be continuing to impose restrictions on family visits to the group home. Those restrictions appear to violate DDS regulations.
As we previously reported, the family of Giovanny Arias, an individual with autism spectrum disorder and other conditions, was prevented from visiting him in the hospital where he was taken after having reportedly fallen down the stairs of his group home on December 19. He suffered injuries, including a broken wrist, black eye, and numerous bruises throughout his body.

Giovanny Arias and his grandmother, Liduvina Gonzalez
Due to the visitation restrictions, the family was deprived of information about Giovanny’s well-being and whereabouts for over a month while he underwent numerous surgical operations, his great aunt, Carolina Hernandez Broomhead, said.
The ban on visiting Giovanny in the hospital followed growing communication and visitation restrictions imposed by Seven Hills management and Giovanny’s state-paid guardian, Susan Braus, in the group home, Carolina said. Carolina contended the restrictions started after the family expressed concerns about insufficient care at the group home.
Visitation restrictions appear to be a part of a pattern in which families are marginalized when they attempt to advocate for their loved ones (see here, here, here).
Previous visitation restrictions at the residence
Issues involving visitation restrictions in Giovanny’s group home first arose this past fall. Carolina contended that Seven Hills and the guardian had responded with visitation restrictions against the family for having alleged that the group home was subjecting Giovanny to poor hygiene and overmedication. Seven Hills also prevented Giovanny’s grandmother from seeing her grandson at the residence, and, at one point, even called the police on the seventy-eight-year-old woman, Carolina said.
Moreover, in November, Seven Hills proposed a series of new restrictions that included a ban on family visits to the residence. Family visits would have to occur at other predetermined locations. There would also be a maximum of two family visits per month with a limit of two hours per visit. Additionally, the family would be required to bring a translator with them on all visits for the benefit of staff who are unable to speak Spanish. A fuller discussion of the restrictions is available here.
Withheld medical updates on the evening of the hospitalization
Existing tension surrounding mistreatment and visitation limitations appeared to escalate during Giovanny’s hospitalization, starting on December 19, at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
That night, Carolina said, she participated in a three-way phone call with a doctor and Braus. She said she heard Braus direct hospital personnel to withhold medical information from the family, even as a doctor recommended otherwise. Consequently, the family was denied vital information about Giovanny’s welfare amid a health emergency, she said.
Family hospital visitation restrictions
Hospital visitation restrictions soon ensued after Giovanny’s admission. While the family was permitted to visit Giovanny at the hospital on December 31, visitation was suddenly restricted on January 2, Carolina said. That day, two security officers unexpectedly ushered another aunt out of the hospital after she attempted to visit Giovanny. Carolina said they did not provide any explanation for the aunt’s removal.
Family difficulties accessing information about hospital visitation restrictions
Shortly afterwards, Carolina called the hospital for more information on the incident. She said a Brigham and Women’s employee claimed to her that Braus had submitted written documentation barring family visits. Carolina said that when she followed up with Braus, however, Braus claimed the hospital was responsible for the visitation ban.
Other attempts by the family to receive clarification of the visitation restrictions in the hospital have been futile, according to Carolina. In an email dated January 13, DDS area director Jeffrey Hetrick claimed that neither DDS nor the guardian had a say in the restrictions, and placed responsibility on the hospital.
Seven Hills Area Director Caelin Scribner similarly asserted that Seven Hills was uninvolved in the decision-making process on visitation, and maintained the hospital alone made the decision to deny family visits. In their emails, both DDS and Scribner encouraged the family to contact the hospital for clarification. Yet, further family outreach to the hospital was unsuccessful, Carolina said, with the hospital hanging up the phone and not responding to emails.
COFAR difficulties assessing responsibility for hospital visitation restrictions
COFAR also experienced similar challenges while investigating the situation. Neither Braus nor Scribner replied to our emails requesting clarification on the hospital visitation restrictions. We emailed DDS Commissioner Sarah Peterson on January 8 to express concerns about the family hospital ban and were told that the DDS Area Office staff would follow up with the family directly. We reached out again on January 26 to the commissioner to highlight that the issue remained and have yet to receive a response.

Giovanny’s broken wrist, which the provider claims he suffered after falling in the group home in December.
Communication with the hospital has proven difficult as well. Despite having a seven-day response timeframe, the hospital didn’t respond to three of our emails about the restrictions. The Brigham and Women’s Patient and Family Relations Department finally replied to us in a January 26 email, stating we would need “a release of information signed by someone who has the authority to speak for the patient.”
While laws protecting health information may limit the public’s ability to receive case details, even our request for basic clarification on hospital visitation policies was not answered by the hospital.
On January 26, I called the floor where Giovanny was hospitalized and was told by a hospital staff member that they could not give me any information and that I would need to speak with Braus instead.
When I clarified that I simply had general questions about the hospital visitation policy, the staff member offered to connect me with a supervisor. After leaving me on hold for about twenty minutes, the staff member returned and said I would have to contact the Patient and Family Relations Department. When I asked if I could speak to the supervisor, the staff member responded that they did not have that person’s contact information.
Implications of the family hospital visitation restrictions
Regardless of who initiated the hospital restrictions, it is concerning that all parties have disclaimed responsibility rather than working to resolve the problem. Each entity has a duty to promote Giovanny’s best interest in partnership with the others.
Isolating an individual with disabilities from his family for over a month cannot be said to advance his best interest. For a person with autism who has limited abilities to communicate with speech, the disruption of routine and exposure to an overwhelming sensory environment in isolation could be traumatic.
The hospital family visitation restrictions seem to be inconsistent with Brigham and Women’s own Patient Rights statement. This affirms that patients have the right to “communicate with people outside of the hospital” and “participate in [their] care.”
The family visitation restrictions also appear to violate Giovanny’s legal rights. His 2024 legal guardianship decree states that Giovanny retains the right “to determine with whom to have friendships and visitation.” No one has claimed that the restrictions stem from Giovanny’s preferences, Carolina said.
Recent hospital discharge and continuing visitation limitations at the group home
In a February 6 email, Braus stated she believes that Giovanny would actually enjoy family visits.
When Giovanny was finally discharged from the hospital recently, Scribner and Braus separately reached out to the family to discuss arranging a visit at the group home. In Braus’ email she commented that she would “imagine [that Giovanny] would appreciate a family visit during his continued recuperation.” According to Carolina, this raises the question why Braus did not intervene to address the month-long hospital visitation restrictions.
Scribner, meanwhile, offered to host a two-hour-long family visit that Sunday with a maximum of two visitors so that Giovanny could “enjoy time with loved ones while still prioritizing his recovery.” She said that future group home visits could not exceed two visitors and would need to have attendees approved by Braus ahead of time. Carolina said it appears that the group home has imposed its November 2025 proposed visitation restriction agreement despite the fact that it was never signed by the family.
In our view, Braus and Seven Hills’ sudden allowance of a group home visit does not negate possible DDS regulation violations. The regulations state that “arrangements shall be made for private visitation to the maximum extent possible” and “family members shall be permitted to visit at all times, unless the individual objects.” Permitting visits sporadically and subjecting visitation to onerous terms and conditions amid growing backlash cannot be said to adhere to the spirit of the regulations.
The hospital visitation restrictions demonstrate the ease with which families can be dismissed and ultimately excluded by major players in the DDS-funded, provider-run residential system. When responsibility is diffused across state agencies, state-paid guardians, and corporate providers, accountability dissolves. Families are reduced from key team members to outsiders while their loved ones with disabilities suffer the fallout.
Family, blocked from visiting group home resident, also barred from visiting him in hospital
A resident of a group home suffered serious injuries there requiring hospitalization, and now his family is barred for undisclosed reasons from visiting him in the hospital.
Late last month, Giovanny Arias, who has autism spectrum disorder and other conditions, reportedly fell down a flight of stairs in the group home, according to his great aunt, Carolina Hernandez Broomhead. The Roslindale home is run by the Seven Hills Foundation, a corporate residential provider funded by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS).
Giovanny’s injuries included a broken wrist, black eye, and numerous bruises across his body, according to Carolina.
While Giovanny has undergone two surgical operations at Brigham & Women’s Hospital in Boston, his family has been prohibited from visiting him there and has been denied medical updates, Carolina said.
The ban on visiting the hospital follows mounting communication and visitation restrictions imposed by the Seven Hills management and by Giovanny’s state-paid guardian, Susan Braus, Carolina said. She said the restrictions began after the family complained of inadequate conditions and poor care at the residence.
Seven Hills even prevented Giovanny’s grandmother from seeing her grandson and, at one point, called police on her, Carolina said. She said Giovanny has been subjected at the residence to poor hygiene and overmedication.
Carolina noted that her family has had to supply all of Giovanny’s clothes, blankets, mattresses, and bed linens, and has had to provide food for him on a weekly basis.
Carolina also said that in November, Seven Hills proposed a series of additional restrictions, including a complete ban on family visits to the group home. Family visits would have to take place at other agreed-upon locations. There would also be a cap of two family visits per month with a maximum duration of two hours per visit.
In addition, the family would be required to bring a translator with them on all visits for the benefit of staff who are unable to speak Spanish. We believe this requirement violates DDS regulations that establish a right of clients to have confidential communications and demonstrates a lack of sensitivity to culturally diverse communities.
As we have been reporting, staff neglect and restrictions on family visitation often go hand in hand in DDS-funded group homes (see here).
Restrictions on visits
According to Carolina, Seven Hills management, DDS, and Braus have blamed the family for failing to act in Giovanny’s best interests. Before his hospitalization, over 100 days had passed since Giovanny last saw any member of his family apart from a single cousin, Carolina said.
Carolina said the Seven Hills group home management blocked Giovanny’s grandmother, Liduvina Gonzalez, from visits and communication with Giovanny after she complained about substandard food and inadequate hygiene. The Seven Hills management called the police on the 78-year-old woman after she attempted to visit her grandson on September 21.
The restrictions appear to violate a 2024 decree naming Braus as Giovanny’s guardian. The decree states that Giovanny retains the right “to determine with whom to have friendships and visitation, with assistance if needed.”
Family response
In response to the alleged neglect and visitation restrictions, Carolina delivered what she termed a “demand letter” on behalf of the family to DDS on November 5. In the letter, she called for inspection and remedy of Giovanny’s current care conditions, his relocation to a more suitable setting, and restored family visitation and communication rights. The rights included regular, in-person visitation and private telephone or video calls at reasonable and scheduled times.
The family has yet to receive any reply to the letter, Carolina said. She said Giovanny’s DDS service coordinator, James Griffin, has ceased responding to her communications since she sent the letter.
Rather than opening a dialogue with DDS and Seven Hills about how to better support Giovanny, the demand letter sparked a wave of new visitation restrictions, according to Carolina. She also said Griffin has excluded her from all meetings related to Giovanny.
Seven Hills visitation restriction agreement
On November 14, the family received a proposed agreement that DDS, Seven Hills, and Braus requested that they sign, listing rigid requirements for family visits and communication with Giovanny. The restrictions include the following:
In-person visits:
- Family visits cannot occur at the group home and can only be scheduled for outside locations agreed upon by both parties in advance.
- Family visits may occur only twice per month on Sundays and must be planned at least a week in advance.
- Family visits are limited to a maximum duration of two hours.
- If a family member needs assistance with personal care, they cannot visit unless accompanied by someone who can provide assistance.
- The family must have an individual present at all visits to translate for the benefit of the staff if the visiting family member is unable to communicate in English. There cannot be more than two people present during any visit.
- Family members are not permitted to bring food to Giovanny under any circumstances.
- Seven Hills can terminate visits at any point they deem “appropriate.”
Phone calls:
- The family can call Giovanny only on Tuesdays and Thursdays after 3 p.m. If Giovanny declines the phone call, the family is not to call back.
- The family is not permitted to call staff or discuss problems unless they are able to speak English or have a translator on the line.
- If at any point in time, the family’s behavior is deemed “negative,” Seven Hills has the right to hang up on the call with notice and organize another time to call with DDS involvement.
Questionable provisions of the restriction agreement
Several of the provisions of the proposed agreement appear to be in violation of DDS regulations, which state that DDS clients have “the right to be visited and to visit others under circumstances that are conducive to friendships and relationships,” and that “family members shall be permitted to visit at all times, unless the individual objects.”
The regulations note that “reasonable restrictions” may be placed on the time and place of visits “to protect the welfare of the individual or the privacy of other individuals and to avoid serious disruptions in the normal functioning of the provider.” However, the regulations require that arrangements be made “for private visitation to the maximum extent possible.”
There is no indication that Giovanny’s family visits have ever adversely affected Giovanny or other residents to warrant such restrictions. The restrictions limiting the number, duration, eligible participants, and locations of visits can hardly be considered to allow for private visitation “to the maximum extent possible.”
We are further concerned by the restrictions’ failure to accommodate the needs of linguistically diverse families. The requirement that family visits occur exclusively in English not only limits meaningful expression that preserves a sense of cultural identity, but also impedes private conversations amongst family members. This also appears to violate DDS regulations, which state that DDS clients maintain “the right to communicate,” including “the opportunity to make and receive confidential communications.”
Escalating health concerns
Carolina said issues involving neglect and visitation restrictions reached a breaking point on December 19, when Giovanny was hospitalized at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
During a three-way telephone call with a doctor and Braus on the evening Giovanny was hospitalized, Carolina said, she heard Braus instruct hospital staff to withhold medical updates from the family, even as a doctor suggested that the information be shared. As a result, the family was deprived of critical information about Giovanny’s health during a medical emergency, she said.
Family visitation restrictions amid medical crisis
Although the family was able to visit Giovanny in the hospital on December 31, they were barred after that from visiting him there, according to Carolina. On January 2, two security officers escorted another aunt out of the hospital after she attempted to see Giovanny, Carolina said.
When Carolina called to inquire about that incident, a Brigham and Women’s staff member told her Braus had submitted written documentation restricting family visitation, Carolina said. She said that when she spoke with Braus, however, Braus denied this and attributed the restrictions to the hospital.
DDS response
We emailed DDS Commissioner Sarah Peterson on December 1, asking the Department to investigate the allegations of neglect at Giovanny’s group home and to allow unrestricted family visits. We were later told that a DDS official would be reaching out to the family directly to address these issues. But Carolina said as of January 6 that no one had contacted her.
The coexistence of neglect and visitation restrictions has been an undercurrent in many of the cases brought to our attention (see here, here, and here), particularly when DDS involves itself in guardianships or co-guardianships.
There is a tendency of DDS and its providers to dismiss family members’ concerns about their loved one’s care as “overly dramatic” and to shut them out rather than investigate and address their allegations. This breakdown of the DDS-funded, provider-run residential system is especially alarming in the context of medical emergencies.
Fostering a DDS culture that acknowledges families as essential partners in collaboration is critical for improving outcomes for people with disabilities.
Support COFAR this Holiday Season
Dear Members and Friends of COFAR,
Thank you for your dedication to the most vulnerable among us with intellectual and developmental disabilities. As we approach the holidays, we want to share our latest work and ask for your ongoing support.
We are continuing to advocate for families and guardians of clients in the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) system, as well as those caught up in the probate court system. We talk to people every day who feel overwhelmed by their treatment by DDS and the courts.
Whether it is attending court hearings as advocates on behalf of family members and guardians or enlisting the help of pro bono attorneys to assist them, we are committed to ensuring their voices are heard.
We are also deepening our outreach to legislators in opposition to bills that would replace guardianship with Supported Decision-Making (SDM), possibly marginalizing family members in the decisions most impacting their loved ones.
And we are working to enlist the aid of legislators and others in our effort to protect our state’s two remaining congregate care facilities—the Wrentham Developmental Center and the Hogan Regional Center. As you know, these centers are under siege by the administration and other proponents of privatized care who fail to recognize that the facilities provide a critical backstop for the care of persons around the state with the most profound levels of intellectual disability and the most serious medical issues.
We are further committed to the preservation and adequate funding of the state’s network of DDS-run group homes as an additional option for families and guardians seeking residential placements for their loved ones. After all, it is imperative that individuals and their families can choose the placements that best align with their needs.
Via our blog site, we provide unparalleled scrutiny of those and other issues, such as excessive compensation paid to provider executives and underpayment of direct-care staff.
Please consider a donation of whatever amount you can afford to help us continue advocating for you. You can contribute by going to our website at www.cofar.org and by clicking on the donate link. Or, you can send a check to our address (12 North Street, Leominster, MA 01453).
Thank you, and happy holidays!
Sincerely,
Thomas J. Frain, Esq.
President






