Mother claims retaliation by DDS in termination of ‘poorly run’ residential program for daughter
In July 2023, the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) created what was described as a novel residential program for two intellectually disabled women who had been subjected to poor care and conditions in a previous group home.
The Department proposed to rent an apartment in Andover for the women, and staff the new residence with direct care workers. Those workers would be employees of Northeast Residential Services (NRS), a division of DDS, which operates group homes in DDS’s Northeast Region of the state.
It was promised by DDS as a long-term solution to the problems associated with the previous placement, and appeared to be a new approach to residential care. It would be a state-run setting that nevertheless promised to be less restrictive and possibly more integrated with the community than would a group home.
It was to be an apartment where the two women could lead independent lives while still receiving Intensive Support Services from DDS.
But DDS suddenly terminated the program last April, only eight months after it began. The mother of one of the two roommates said the termination was an act of retaliation against her daughter for having reported an incident of alleged emotional abuse of her daughter by a staff member.
We are not listing the mother’s and daughter’s names at the mother’s request.
The mother maintains that far from providing better care than the previous group home had provided, DDS never appeared to be committed to making the new residential program work. Soon after the women moved into the apartment on July 4, 2023, the mother said, she realized that only four staff were being made available to the women even though both need care 24/7. As was the case with her daughter’s previous group home, few activities were provided in the apartment, she said.
Then, in September 2023, just two months into the program, NRS removed the part-time residential manager of the residence.
That month, the mother sent an email to NRS administrators, contending the staff were failing to provide exercise activities for her daughter and were allowing the daughter to spend her money on junk food even though she had contracted diabetes after engaging in that same behavior in her previous residence.
And, the mother wrote, the staff in the new residence were failing to provide information about meals served there; were not working with her daughter to participate in household activities such as cleaning her room or doing laundry; and were not providing community-engagement activities for her.
Termination appeared to be an act of retaliation for abuse complaint
According to the mother, rather than agreeing to investigate and resolve her concerns, DDS administrators became dismissive and increasingly hostile toward her.
Then came an incident on February 20, 2024, when the mother was talking with her daughter over the phone and overheard a staff member begin shouting at her daughter to get back in her room. Her daughter had been attempting to do her laundry, but the staff member would not let her do it. She said her daughter began crying.
The mother said she tried calling both NRS and DDS to express her concern about the situation. But there was no response, so she drove to apartment. Still unable to get any answers, she filed a complaint with the Disabled Persons Protection Commission (DPPC).
This was not the first such incident involving the staff and the daughter. The mother said this incident had followed an incident a few months prior in which a staff member, while driving her daughter back from her day program, had threatened to kick the daughter out of the car and leave her on the side of the road because she was crying.
In addition, staff in the apartment often bullied the daughter, according to the mother, by doing such things as sending her to her room for being “annoying,” and refusing to let her leave the table after meals until she ate everything on her plate. They often refused to answer questions she had about completing tasks.
On February 21, 2024, a day after the mother filed her DPPC complaint, NRS Director Scott Kluge emailed her, contending she had misrepresented the incident in the laundry room, and accusing the mother of “continuing to create a toxic environment for your daughter to live in and for our staff to work in.” As usual, the mother said, DDS and NRS were blaming her for shortcomings in care, for which they themselves were responsible.
Kluge, who had not been present in the residence at the time of the laundry incident, maintained that the mother’s “behavior was unacceptable,” and then said, “I strongly encourage you to work with the (DDS) Area Office to discuss other service options as clearly this is not working.”
The mother contends that Kluge’s February 21 email was a not-too-subtle threat that he might evict the daughter from the program in retaliation for her mother’s complaint to the DPPC.
Then, on February 23, 2024, just two days later, Kluge emailed the mother to tell her that the residential program would indeed be terminated in roughly a month, and that the cause was a staffing shortage. But the mother pointed out that no such shortage was indicated in the daughter’s Individual Support Plan (ISP), which had been completed and processed by DDS on February 12, just over a week before. The ISP did not identify any concerns about her supports or services.
But DDS was not done. On the same day that Kluge announced the termination of the program, DDS’s legal division petitioned in Middlesex Probate Court to limit or possibly eliminate The mother’s and her husband’s co-guardianship of their daughter. That action had come out of the blue. There was no indication in the daughter’s ISP that she didn’t need guardianship from her parents.
The mother said that DDS eventually withdraw its petition, but only after she had initiated discovery proceedings against DDS in the case.
Unfortunately, the mother’s allegations about the Andover program appear to jibe with complaints we’ve heard from many family members and guardians that both DDS and its corporate providers retaliated against them when they raised concerns about poor care and conditions in DDS-funded programs. (See some examples of that can be found here, here, here, here, and here.)
State Senator Kennedy and other legislators ‘ignored us’
Partly at our suggestion, the mother sought support from key state legislators before and after the program termination, particularly from the co-chairs of the Children, Families, and Persons with Disabilities Committee. She did manage to arrange two virtual meetings with a member of the staff of State Senator Robyn Kennedy, Senate chair of the committee.
But the mother said that while Kennedy’s aide had promised to set up a meeting with the senator, to which her daughter wanted to go, that promise wasn’t kept. She added that she also emailed Representative Jay Livingstone, House chair of the Children and Families Committee, and the rest of the committee members, but never heard back from them.
Pushing ‘self-directed services’
The mother contends that in addition to reacting negatively when she raised concerns about her daughter’s care in the residence, DDS officials began pushing her to adopt a “self-directed services” model under which the daughter would live and receive services in her parents’ home. Under self-direction, the individual or their guardian is given a budget by DDS and is directed to choose their own services and hire their own staff.
Many advocates and family members have expressed frustration that statutory requirements governing self-directed services are not being met by DDS, and that the Department’s allocated budgets are inadequate.
Nevertheless, when the mother complained in September 2023 about a lack of activities for her daughter and other problems in the residence, DDS Northeast Regional Director Kelly Lawless replied in an email that, “I want to reply to make sure you understand that if you are not satisfied with the services that NRS provides, you should reach out to the Area Office to discuss Self-Direction.”
But the mother said that while she did express interest in learning more about self-directed services, DDS never specified a budget for it even though she had asked repeatedly for that information.
Program termination appealed
The mother has now launched the second of two administrative appeals of the termination of the apartment program, arguing that it amounted to an eviction of her daughter and her roommate without complying with regulations requiring DDS to offer her improved services elsewhere.
The mother’s first appeal, which was filed shortly before the program was terminated in March 2024, was quashed by DDS in what appears to have been a violation of a DDS statute and regulation that allow clients to appeal “transfers” from one DDS-funded residence to another. As a result, she refiled her appeal with the state Division of Administrative Law Appeals (DALA) in December.
By way of disclosure, I am acting as the mother’s advocate in seeking a DALA hearing in that refiled appeal. DDS initially objected to my role, but was overruled by the DALA magistrate. However, DDS has also filed a motion to dismiss her appeal. We have filed briefs objecting to the Department’s motion.
DDS is continuing to use an argument, first employed against the mother at the time the program was terminated, that she has no grounds to appeal to DALA because she took her daughter back home with her and her husband just days before the termination, and therefore no appealable “transfer” actually took place.
Our response to that argument is that the mother and her husband had no choice but to take their daughter home because all services were about to end in the apartment. We maintain that DDS’s argument was and is disingenuous. The termination of the services amounted an eviction of the daughter; and that eviction was effectively a transfer. The only difference between an eviction and a transfer is there is no suitable alternative location in an eviction.
We are asking DALA to order DDS to comply with all of the provisions of the transfer statute by acting with reasonable promptness to find another residential program for the daughter, which would provide her with improved services and meet all requirements in her ISP. In the meantime, we argue, DDS should be ordered to provide sufficient supports and staffing to the daughter in her current location to meet those same ISP requirements.
Daughter’s supports and services continue to be inadequate
Since April 1, 2024, the daughter has continued to reside in her parents’ home. While the husband is now paid as a shared living caregiver for his daughter, the mother maintains that both she and her husband, who are in their 60s, are “overwhelmed with the challenges of providing the daughter’s intensive supports and maintaining our commitments to our full time jobs.”
The mother said she and her husband are dedicating the majority of their time to her daughter’s care, including her need for activities, companionship, nutrition, medication, medical appointments, and legal challenges. But it has been inadequate because DDS has not provided the daughter with physical therapy nursing, or counseling services for the past year. She said her daughter continues to have night terrors and has become more timid and inhibited as a result of the treatment she received from some of the staff in the apartment.
Yet the daughter wants to be independent, the mother said. “She wants to live in a home with a housemate with similar interests and goals and she wants to have friends,” the mother added. “She wants to live a full meaningful life in accordance with the DDS rules and regulations. She is not asking for anything above that. It should not be impossible.”
The mother said that in March of last year, with the termination of the apartment program looming, DDS Northeast Regional Director Kelly Lawless told her that, “‘What you (the mother) are seeking does not exist in DDS.'” She said she responded to Lawless that she “was advocating for adequate care and intensive supports for her daughter. I asked her why that doesn’t exist in DDS, and she said that, ‘Your expectations are too high.'”
Clearly, expecting adequate care is not an unreasonably high expectation.
The daughter herself seemed to sum it up during a bill sharing session hosted earlier this month by the Massachusetts Developmental Disabilities Council (MDDC), which the daughter participated in via Zoom. “I want to help people and be a part of the community,” she said during the recorded session, with her mother sitting beside her.
The daughter was helped in drafting her statement by a graduate student from Brandeis who was interning with the MDDC. “I want a home where I feel safe and with nice staff that will not yell at me and tell me to stay in my room,” she added. “I want to make choices about my life.”
awful what they do to our kids
Appealing to DALA sounds like a good idea. I didn’t know you can do that. I also think that the mother should try to file an Olmstead complaint. File a Complaint | ADA.gov . Massachusetts HHS has a grievance process for violations of CMS’s Home and Community-Based Rule, though its effectiveness is uncertain due to widespread noncompliance for many individuals with IDD. The daughter’s story is just one of many examples of widespread noncompliance with the HCBS settings rule. Concerns can be submitted at https://www.mass.gov/info-details/community-rule-grievance-process. So, the state has violated HCBS settings rule in this case because the daughter is supposed to be protected from wrongful eviction. She should have had a lease or residency agreement. Of course, nobody does. Settings must be integrated into and support full access to the greater community. This includes opportunities for individuals to seek employment, work in competitive settings, engage in community life, control their personal resources, and receive services just like individuals not receiving Medicaid HCBS. Yeah, they didn’t do that. I am sick and tired of the PR that individuals are receiving this when they aren’t. In addition to being active members of COFAR, we need to fight this sort of thing on a national level as well. I hope that the mother and father will consider joining Voice of Reason (VOR) and also become active nationally.
DDS, DPPC and Legislators continue to cover up abuse and violations of civil and human rights. They continuously fail to meet minimum federal standards. With Area Directors like Kelly it’s not surprising.
Oppression needs to end. Legislators need to be voted out. They are failing by choose not mistake.
It is so sad to hear these stories. And yes, over the years I have learned to lower my expectations of my family member’s care. Staff are frequently on their phones, sitting in the office, or washing their cars, etc. In nearly 5 years, I have never witnessed a staff member having a conversation or playing a game with a client. Clients are each in their rooms watching TV. My family member is left sitting alone in the kitchen, often. I visit often to: do activities, organizational tasks (like clean the closet), personal care and of course, companionship. I pay a family friend to visit, as well. I attend nearly all medical and dental appointments and make sure follow up appointments are made. While this is more that I thought I would need to do, it seems necessary to keep care going smoothly. My special requests like a suction device to remove excessive toothpaste are met with a “no.” On the positive side, at his current group home I have never witnessed staff yelling or being demeaning to the clients. Staff keep my family member clean and arrange transportation to his day care. They are kind to him.